abortion: pro or against? | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
(nobody)
...and 313 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2614114
Today 0
Topics 127542
  
 
Messageboard index
abortion: pro or against?
 

offline Laserbeak from Netherlands, The on 2002-10-21 07:14 [#00411266]
Points: 2670 Status: Lurker | Followup to Ceri JC: #00411232



"But what if you have a supremacist couple who see having a
baby with dark hair as wrong? As technology improves this
will become a real issue..."

when parents make up a bad reason to kill the unborn baby
then I'm against it of course because in that case it falls
under the "kill the baby out of convenience" category. To
form an opinion on this I first have to know the problem
then I decide then the parents(all this in theory of course)


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-10-21 07:17 [#00411268]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to korben dallas: #00411265 | Show recordbag



I definately believe in "degrees" rather than absolutes in
illness, esp. relating to mental illness. People may only
have miled OCD and be able to conquer it. It's not as clean
cut as you're OCD or you're not, I think most people have a
slight hint of acting in a compulsive way from time to time,
just as most people have a hint of synesthasia (the
"condition", not the artistic quality).


 

offline korben dallas from nz on 2002-10-21 07:21 [#00411270]
Points: 4605 Status: Regular



"stronger will" thats quite a loaded term there :)

and yeah .. i " flea .. the either/or thing begs controversy
.. i



 

offline pOgO from behind your belly button fluff on 2002-10-21 07:30 [#00411272]
Points: 12687 Status: Lurker



I'm well pro on abortion, but I don;t think that it should
be used as an excuse not to use protection.

At the end of the day, acidents happen and if it's the wrong
place at the wrong time it's not fair on you or the child.

I think also you have to be a little selfish in these
situations, cause you may resent the child if your life
doesn't go as planned, and again this is just not fair


 

offline jonesy from Lisboa (Portugal) on 2002-10-21 07:38 [#00411278]
Points: 6650 Status: Lurker



At the end of the day, its the woman's body and she has a
right to do as she pleases, ultimately.

But abortions can be really traumatic so they aren't used as
a form of post-contraception.


 

offline pOgO from behind your belly button fluff on 2002-10-21 07:44 [#00411284]
Points: 12687 Status: Lurker



You can't actually have a baby aborted if you're 6months or
over

there are also 3 types of abortion you can have depending on
your stage of pregnancy:

the 1st is to take a pill which will force miscarrage, the
2nd is to go anuder and have an operation which will remove
the featus and "other stuff" (ewe), the 3rd is to have
induced labour


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-10-21 08:00 [#00411309]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to pOgO: #00411284 | Show recordbag



"2nd is to go anuder and have an operation..."

What's "anuder"?


 

offline pOgO from behind your belly button fluff on 2002-10-21 08:10 [#00411336]
Points: 12687 Status: Lurker



oops =os

I meant "under" as in Anaesthetic


 

offline smokehammer from Saigon (Vietnam) on 2002-10-21 08:10 [#00411339]
Points: 1463 Status: Lurker



perhaps people need to experiment more with non-reproductive
forms of sex...

some girls only seem to want to stick with drunken
mish-position fumblings under the covers and thats part of
the problem...

They should be forced to watch Randy West videos and then
expand their... um .. horizons..
(with me) :P


 

offline Desdemona from Lake Mendota on 2002-10-21 08:35 [#00411380]
Points: 630 Status: Lurker



I think abortion needs to kept legal - if you'll look at all
the reasons listed for it above, and what fine lines they
run on, it's too hard to see what is and isn't legitimte -
and if the legality of each and every abortion was handed
over to a court, or simply suspended, many women would be
unjustly served. Women would be required to stand long
court to justify whether or not what had happened to them
was rape, and whether they were eligible for abortion. It's
not a thing easily or frequently admitted to, and it is
always traumatic, and shattering - not anything that should
ever have to be widely exposed. I have read hundreds of
abortion cases and never seen one that wasn't traumatic and
shattering as well - abortion isn't used as a 'oh well, I'll
just do it' thing in case of pregnancy, its an awful ordeal
that leaves many women severely depressed for decades.
Granted it needs to be taught more clearly that NO means of
birthcontrol is 100% effective, and that seeing to
birthcontrol is the responsibility of both partners, never
just one. To end a life for no reason is wrong, but who
gets to decide what reason is just?


 

offline diemax from somewhere in tennessee :( (United States) on 2002-10-21 08:37 [#00411383]
Points: 2040 Status: Lurker



i'm against
i think all women should be euthanized before they reach
childbearing age, and the rest of us should twiddle our
lives away with internet porn and narcotics

cheers


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-10-21 08:43 [#00411394]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to diemax: #00411383 | Show recordbag



Good point. I think that's the best compromise...

Pogo: I just noticed your "=os" smiley looks like = OS as
in, is equal to operating system :)


 

offline pOgO from behind your belly button fluff on 2002-10-21 08:48 [#00411402]
Points: 12687 Status: Lurker | Followup to Ceri JC: #00411394



well done Ceri !

lol


 

offline smokehammer from Saigon (Vietnam) on 2002-10-21 08:49 [#00411406]
Points: 1463 Status: Lurker



oh for heavens sakes diemax,

do you really need women to die in order for you to continue
your lifestyle ? :D

Oh sorry , you mean you want to see more snuff &
necrophilia... and they say porn de-sensitizes Duh !!! ;)


 

offline uviol from United States on 2002-10-21 10:01 [#00411567]
Points: 2496 Status: Lurker



pogo> realized I never responded in the death penalty
thread..
" Your 19 right? Look back at when you were like 16-17 years
old. What would
you do if you got a girl of a simular age preggers?? You
have your whole life ahead of you, not much money to
support yourself let alone a child and still living with
your parents. Would you really bring a child into the world
knowing that it'll probably grow up in a poor enviroment?"
..
my answer> I wouldn't *want* to bring a child into the
world, but that doesn't mean I would kill/abort it. The
child, if left alone, would become another human being.. my
kid no less! I would take responsibility for my
carelessness and become an early father. If I did not have
the means to support it, I would put it up for adoption or
find an alternative. I think abortion, though very
practical, has significant ethical problems and should be
avoided. I for one could not live with the guilt of knowing
I destroyed what was potentially my child. I would not want
to put my hypothetical girlfriend through that either.
Better to have the child and struggle through with it tha
abort it and live with guilt and speculation. That's not
even considering that the child may serve some *beneficial*
latent function. It could bring on the maturity a
struggling, delinquint youth needs.. it could bring joy and
love into your life despite the initial regret and probable
financial difficulty. Bottom line: better to have it and
deal than abort and regret.



 

offline zzligg from Allen,TX (United States) on 2002-10-21 10:02 [#00411571]
Points: 347 Status: Addict



it's the womans choice. I wouldn't indoctrinate my views
against it on anyone.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-10-21 10:03 [#00411575]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to uviol: #00411567 | Show recordbag



Yeah, if I had a kid, I'd just apply myself more, get a
better paying job and grow up a bit more. I'd def. be a
better father than most of the fuck ups in my home town...


 

offline Binaural Tea from Christmas City (Christmas Island) on 2002-10-21 10:04 [#00411576]
Points: 1912 Status: Lurker



oh i dont give a damn.


 

offline Binaural Tea from Christmas City (Christmas Island) on 2002-10-21 10:04 [#00411578]
Points: 1912 Status: Lurker



i´ll probably have an opinion when i become a daddy.


 

offline xlr from Boston (United States) on 2002-10-21 10:09 [#00411589]
Points: 4904 Status: Regular



I think that Abortion should be legal, and the option should
be open to all women if they choose to do so.

I mostly agree w/ Laserbeak. I think abortion should be a
"last resort" option. If a woman is impregnated through
non-consentual sex, such as rape, incest, etc. And also if
she is incapable of raising her child, or if the
contraceptives failed during sex.

I think more people should consider adoption. There are
many childless couples out there who want a baby. Of
course, the adoption system in the US is plagued with
problems, and that needs to be worked on first.


 

offline Monoid from one source all things depend on 2002-10-21 10:14 [#00411595]
Points: 11010 Status: Lurker



PRO


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-10-21 10:16 [#00411599]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to xlr: #00411589 | Show recordbag



I also think people should adopt rather than have kids of
their own if they really want kids...


 

offline Smyrma from Beloit, WI (United States) on 2002-10-21 10:20 [#00411607]
Points: 2478 Status: Lurker



Pro-choice..

I can't make other people's decisions for them.


 

offline Smyrma from Beloit, WI (United States) on 2002-10-21 10:27 [#00411620]
Points: 2478 Status: Lurker



I should say "..regarding controversial issues like this"


 

offline electro from detroit on 2002-10-22 09:31 [#00412934]
Points: 2880 Status: Regular



pro


 

offline LuckyPsycho from a long way from home (United Kingdom) on 2002-10-22 09:33 [#00412942]
Points: 369 Status: Lurker



Definately Pro choice


 

offline LuckyPsycho from a long way from home (United Kingdom) on 2002-10-22 09:33 [#00412945]
Points: 369 Status: Lurker



Definately Pro choice


 

offline ward from Cheshire (United Kingdom) on 2002-10-22 09:34 [#00412947]
Points: 316 Status: Addict



I don't give a shit tbh...

people can do whatever they like.



 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-10-22 09:35 [#00412953]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to LuckyPsycho: #00412945 | Show recordbag



All righ, all right, saying it twice just makes people think
you're some kind of zealot ;)


 

offline qrter from the future, and it works (Netherlands, The) on 2002-10-22 09:35 [#00412954]
Points: 47414 Status: Moderator | Followup to ward: #00412947



in an inarticulate way you're saying you're pro..


 

offline qrter from the future, and it works (Netherlands, The) on 2002-10-22 09:35 [#00412955]
Points: 47414 Status: Moderator | Followup to Ceri JC: #00412953



I love the word 'zealot'. just how it looks..


 

offline Sepix from Major City (Austria) on 2002-10-22 09:36 [#00412957]
Points: 3110 Status: Lurker



of course pro. no further arguments needed - no one would do
this for fun ...


 

offline zguru from Lindale (Texas) (United States) on 2002-10-22 09:37 [#00412962]
Points: 1562 Status: Regular



so if you are pro abortion... you are neither pro choice of
pro life... you just want to abort babies regardless of the
situation.

i'm pro life... but i don't care what other people are


 

offline qrter from the future, and it works (Netherlands, The) on 2002-10-22 09:39 [#00412971]
Points: 47414 Status: Moderator | Followup to zguru: #00412962



read my very first message.


 

offline earthleakage from tell the world you're winning on 2002-10-22 09:40 [#00412972]
Points: 27795 Status: Regular



you don't care what other people are?
that says it all really


 

offline zguru from Lindale (Texas) (United States) on 2002-10-22 09:42 [#00412982]
Points: 1562 Status: Regular



well, i've made my choices, and i wish everyone felt the way
i do, but it's never going to be that way.


 

offline earthleakage from tell the world you're winning on 2002-10-22 09:46 [#00412992]
Points: 27795 Status: Regular



you wish everyone felt like you do? hopefully not about
everything. how boring would life be if everyone agreed all
the time!


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-10-22 09:51 [#00413001]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to qrter: #00412955 | Show recordbag



Yep, and the imagery it conjures up... Nice "ancient"
sounding word like Ziggurut :)


 

offline Sido Dyas from a computer on 2002-10-22 10:22 [#00413044]
Points: 8876 Status: Lurker



pro abortion. Of course! Where not living in the 20's!
The "baby" is in 99% of the time only a little maggot thingy
with no mind of its own.
If one should fully justyfieng being against abortion he
should also be like the tibetian monks and always be
careful where you step so you don't kill any little buggs!

Im against leather pants tho...


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-10-22 10:23 [#00413046]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to Sido Dyas: #00413044 | Show recordbag



I am careful not to kill insects...
But I do have a leather jacket :os


 

offline LuckyPsycho from a long way from home (United Kingdom) on 2002-10-22 10:24 [#00413047]
Points: 369 Status: Lurker



surely everyone is against leather pants.. it just not done


 

offline Elastic from Zidum (Kiribati) on 2002-10-22 10:26 [#00413051]
Points: 242 Status: Regular



Pro-Abortion haha

yeah, kill those stupid babies!


 

offline Elastic from Zidum (Kiribati) on 2002-10-22 10:27 [#00413053]
Points: 242 Status: Regular



seriously though I'm pro-choice. it's not up to me to
decide, it's the woman's body, therefore it's her choice


 

offline Netlon Sentinel from eDe (Netherlands, The) on 2002-10-22 11:14 [#00413089]
Points: 4736 Status: Lurker



i'm against

but when you think of it... the world is really crowded and
i wouldn't wanna put a baby on this miserable world anyway
these days. i mean, it's bad enough that less and less ppl
clear off because of our finding cures for the various
epidemics and diseases...

this way, it isn't survival of the fittest; ieverybody gets
to survive in this society... the human race will lose the
evolutionary race if things continue to be like they are
today... :(

but my instinct still says abortion is murder of the lowest
kind -> the baby can't defend itself...

euthanasia is another matter, though.

sad thing is, i'm being serious thru all the above :)


 

offline Bremzen from utrecht (Netherlands, The) on 2002-10-22 12:03 [#00413119]
Points: 653 Status: Lurker



pro


 

offline surrounded from it won't be hard anymore to li on 2002-10-22 13:07 [#00413154]
Points: 3787 Status: Regular



pro-choice ofcourse. It's never an easy dissicion (i mean
for a woman who is considering an abortion). And you can be
sure she will think very carefully about it... i don't think
anyone would ever think of abortion as a means of
anticonception :-/ It's a good thing that people should
atleast have the option to choose for an abortion.

And i don't really think of it as murder. Doctors will only
perform an abortion in the earliest stage of pregnancy...
technically speeking those cells are alive ofcourse... but
it's not really aware of anything yet. That baby won't know
what it's missing if it never gets born... it's a sad thing,
but not murder imo


 

offline surrounded from it won't be hard anymore to li on 2002-10-22 13:13 [#00413158]
Points: 3787 Status: Regular | Followup to uviol: #00411567



"my answer> I wouldn't *want* to bring a child into the
world, but that doesn't mean I would kill/abort it."

But don't you think your child would feel very unwelcome if
it was born under those circumstances? A mistake that was
never supposed to happen... only allowed to live because you
felt it was wrong to have it killed.

I think all children deserve to be born into a loving family
that has been looking forward to them and think of them as a
beautiful gift.

Ofcourse you would still be able to love your child, if it
was born more or less "by mistake"... but i think there is a
difference, and as it grows older your child will understand
the situation in which it was born. :-/


 

offline Laserbeak from Netherlands, The on 2002-10-22 13:39 [#00413167]
Points: 2670 Status: Lurker | Followup to surrounded: #00413158



"And i don't really think of it as murder"
yes, murder is a bad description because it involves the
killing: A: has to be unlawful(varies from country to
country) and B: involves premeditated malice (highly
unlikely with abortion)

"but it's not really aware of anything yet. That baby won't
know what it's missing if it never gets born..."

I don't really know about the first part but I think the
second part is a bit reversed: People never knew what they
were missing because they never saw the baby....

"But don't you think your child would feel very unwelcome if
it was born under those circumstances?"

I think that this is speculation and besides: a human being
is much more than the product of it's parent's (good or
bad)influence. This all makes making a decision very very
hard.


 

offline surrounded from it won't be hard anymore to li on 2002-10-22 14:06 [#00413178]
Points: 3787 Status: Regular



I don't really want to get technical about the word 'murder'
really... i just meant i don't really see abortion as the
killing of a child. Or if you will: ending the life of a
child.

At what point do a couple of cells become a child? We don't
consider a spermcel or the female egg "life" yet... but on
the second those two are combined the anti-abortion people
feel it needs to be protected.

I can pretty much understand all your arguments (and
actually all the anti-abortion arguments)... but what it
comes down to i guess is that i look at it more from the
parent's perspective. You might be saving the life of the
unborn child, but at the same time destroying the future of
two young children who are not ready to become parents at
all yet. (in the case someone wants an abortion for being
too young... there are also other reasons ofcourse).

It's the parents decision, and for them it's hard enough as
it is... the last thing they need is pro-life activists
accusing them of murder :-/


 

offline uviol from United States on 2002-10-22 14:34 [#00413187]
Points: 2496 Status: Lurker



"And i don't really think of it as murder. Doctors will only

perform an abortion in the earliest stage of pregnancy... "


this actually isn't taking partial-birth abortions into
account, which is another controversy altogether..

I have to agree with Laserbeak on many of these points..
surrounded you said that a child wqould feel bad if it knew
it was "only allowed to live because you
felt it was wrong to have it killed." Wouldn't the child
then be grateful for this sens eof maorality? Isn't it
better this way than saying to the child "We wanted to have
you aborted but didn't have enough money" or "you were
already too far developed" or something?
All this is not to mention that you're discarding potential
lives.. Have you ever read "the Scarlet Letter"? The
illegitimate child, the symbol of the main character's
immorality, also became one of the greatest sources of joy
for its despairing mother. Letting a child live, even if
you decide to let someone else raise it, may be the best
thing that's ever happened to you regardless of the initial
disappointment and unwant (is that a word?). Anyway, I feel
that abortion should be avoided since there's so many
alternatives and possibilities that are destroyed upon an
aborted pregnancy.




 


Messageboard index