Samples vs synthesis | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
Now online (2)
big
Monoid
...and 297 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2613477
Today 3
Topics 127503
  
 
Messageboard index
Samples vs synthesis
 

offline GQontheEQ from Wirral (United Kingdom) on 2002-08-15 19:20 [#00351138]
Points: 5 Status: Lurker



I think in the 00's musicians are moving away from samples,
and more towards programming tunes from scratch.
Timbaland is a good example of this in hip-hop.



 

offline Zeus from San Francisco (United States) on 2002-08-15 19:23 [#00351142]
Points: 14042 Status: Lurker



if you mean samples as in entire loops, ripped of from a
song a la Puffy daddy, yes

but samples in music will always remain


 

offline kluizenaar from Netherlands Antilles on 2002-08-15 19:28 [#00351146]
Points: 506 Status: Regular



must agree with zeus.

A lot of the synthesised sounds in modern music today are
also sampled. Hell ,when making a mixdown everything gets
recorded to wave/aiff for further treatment with plugins.

Though I agree with you that the tendency in (popular)Hip
Hop these days is more electronically inspired. A lot of
Korg triton presets also, which I fucking hate!


 

offline map from mülligen (Switzerland) on 2002-08-15 19:54 [#00351169]
Points: 3408 Status: Lurker



samples for natural sounds, synthesizers for fat, digital,
fm tunes..


 

offline LPB from Regina (Canada) on 2002-08-15 20:06 [#00351184]
Points: 128 Status: Lurker



I don't know, both are good.


 

offline map from mülligen (Switzerland) on 2002-08-15 20:10 [#00351189]
Points: 3408 Status: Lurker



synthesis is underrated, less peoples of this world really
use the power of FM. and yeah, like kluizenaar (cool name)
said, samples can sound like synthesized tunes..


 

offline Clic on 2002-08-15 20:10 [#00351190]
Points: 5232 Status: Regular



I think it's funny that you use TIMBALAND as an example.

For the record, Timbaland is one of the biggest sacks of
talentless shit out there right now.

Also, I am on the same page as Zeus.


 

offline evolume from seattle (United States) on 2002-08-15 20:27 [#00351206]
Points: 10965 Status: Regular | Followup to Clic: #00351190



timbaland is one of the only popular hip hop producers who
is doing anything interesting with beats and melody.
listen to the first 6 or so tracks of the most recent
Timbaland & Magoo album. Lyrically, i concede that the
album is pretty mediocre but the programming is very
original and groundbreaking for the Pop music genre. also,
the track "Indian Carpet" (i think its called) has some fine
examples of incorporating unlikely samples into hip hop.


 

offline map from mülligen (Switzerland) on 2002-08-15 20:30 [#00351210]
Points: 3408 Status: Lurker



that's wrong, check tipper, rjd2, dj shadow. not popular,
but good.


 

offline Laserbeak from Netherlands, The on 2002-08-15 20:57 [#00351248]
Points: 2670 Status: Lurker



hmmm, I think hiphop is more hiphop when there's only
turntables and scratching, not too much computerstuff. It
has to stay raw IMO


 

offline kluizenaar from Netherlands Antilles on 2002-08-15 21:00 [#00351252]
Points: 506 Status: Regular



ok, to add to the Hip Hop conversation. The only Hip Hop I
like at the moment is any production from Madlib .

Check out : quasimoto now if you've never heard of 'em!


 

offline evolume from seattle (United States) on 2002-08-16 00:44 [#00351388]
Points: 10965 Status: Regular | Followup to kluizenaar: #00351252



Quasimoto "the unseen" is a brilliant fucking album.
Cheers kluizenaar!


 

offline evolume from seattle (United States) on 2002-08-16 00:49 [#00351395]
Points: 10965 Status: Regular | Followup to map: #00351210



map,
i just meant "popular" like top 40, on american radio, mtv
video's, mtv cribs etc etc like popular.

Laserbeak,
agreed, hip hop generally should have some turney's and
scratching i.e. da raw shit. but thats what i was pointing
out about Timbaland; that he is incorporating some
experimental electronic sounds/beats/progressions and trying
to do something new with the genre.

also check his use of vocal layering. On the new timbaland
magoo album especially.

another Hip Hop guy who is trying to change things up I
would say is BUsta Rhymes. he has a few tracks that don't
even use 4/4 which is pretty much the standard time
signature in hip-hop.


 

offline Paco from Gothenburg (Sweden) on 2002-08-16 01:00 [#00351409]
Points: 2659 Status: Lurker



One of my fave things to do on a synth is polyphonic
portamento (Juno-106). Samples can't do this and even
monophonic portamento gets choppy when using multisamples.
Gliding with one sample is fine, but is restricted,
especially going up in pitch.

-P


 

offline titsworth from Washington, DC (United States) on 2002-08-16 02:15 [#00351561]
Points: 14550 Status: Lurker



don't dis timbaland unless you can make beats that sound
better (and prove it)


 

offline hepburnenthorpe from sydney (Australia) on 2002-08-16 02:48 [#00351617]
Points: 1365 Status: Lurker



i really think synthesis is the way to go. firstly youve got
heaps more control over every parametre of the sound. you
can tweak it while its playing, automate it to change while
its playing. and secondly it means you can create the exact
sound you wont, instead of looking through thousands of
samples till you find one close to what you want, then
trying to manipulate that with fx untill its closer to what
you want.

i used fastracker and the like for years, have a collection
of around 18 gig of samples. but since getting a few
hardware synths and more recently getting into the ni range
of vsti's, i couldnt go back to sample based tunes.
i still use samples for most my drum work, although more
recently ive even been synthesising them myself and them
sampling them back in. ive never been into loops AT ALL. but
yeeah, i think sampling plays a huge part, but those samples
should be from an original source. and synthesis will always
be the bigger part of my productions.


 

offline pachi from yo momma (United States) on 2002-08-16 02:53 [#00351623]
Points: 8984 Status: Lurker



concept-wise, i go synth


 

offline Equal from United States on 2002-08-16 03:21 [#00351640]
Points: 5 Status: Lurker



I think it's apples/oranges. Sampling (to me) is taking a
sound from the real world I hear that has interesting
phonetic qualities (usually by minidisc) and integrating it
with my track of music. Synthesizing is using a machine to
create pitched tones (like traditional instruments) or FX
and manipulating its parameters. Synths add the musical
qualities of chords and tripped out effects, while samples
introduce real world wavforms with dynamics that could never
be (or would never be) synthesized (also tripped out).
Sampling a synth or drum machine is going backwards. How
about creating new music with your own sounds and tweaked
instruments? or is that to creative to be popular? heh, i
guess it's called underground for a reason.

-Bored with copycats-
=Equal=


 

offline Quoth from Sweden on 2002-08-16 04:10 [#00351664]
Points: 3840 Status: Lurker | Followup to evolume: #00351206



you do remember that DR. DRE... CO-PRODUCED some of Trent
Reznor's stuff off of THE FRAGILE?


 

offline USACID from Death Valley (Zambia) on 2002-08-16 04:55 [#00351687]
Points: 788 Status: Lurker



...samplin is for fools, synthesis is for smarties :0) LIke
anything sampling is just a tool to use...unfort. everyone
and their sister is over using it.

oh yea, puff daddy and the entire hip-hop community are no
talents =)


 

offline wayout from the street of crocodiles on 2002-08-16 07:45 [#00351778]
Points: 2849 Status: Lurker



i actually think that with so much emphasis on computer
software..artists are moving more towards sampling...but not
in the traditional sense, like taking a bit from another
song and looping it... i mean like what artists like matmos
do.. taking sampled sounds and affecting them and arranging
them... which was something that wasnt as easy to do with
hardware..
but i dont mean to say that artists are moving away from
synthesis.. i think both sampling and synthesis will always
be progressing together with the technology...and as zeus
said, i think both will always be equally important in
electronic music


 

offline titsworth from Washington, DC (United States) on 2002-08-16 07:46 [#00351780]
Points: 14550 Status: Lurker | Followup to Quoth: #00351664



that's not quite true. he assisted with the mixing of "even
deeper", that's all.

.....however, dre and trent have a few unreleased songs
together.


 

offline wayout from the street of crocodiles on 2002-08-16 07:49 [#00351788]
Points: 2849 Status: Lurker



ack.. i contradicted myself, i know...

but anyways..as far as hip hop goes...
anti pop claim to create all their sounds themselves..so
theres a good example of completely synthesized hip hop...
and dont forget push button objects..
oh, and el-p is pretty good at that too...though he
intergrates a bit more samples into his stuff



 

offline Clic on 2002-08-16 07:56 [#00351798]
Points: 5232 Status: Regular | Followup to evolume: #00351206



In regards to: "timbaland is one of the only popular hip hop
producers who
is doing anything interesting with beats and melody."

What? How about, no? He does some of the most GENERIC
melodies AND beats ever. They're very, very redundant and
just go nowhere. Sorry, I just don't see the 'magic' in
Timbaland's 'music'. It's just boring. Not interesting. I
don't see how there is anything that could be considered
interesting in mainstream hiphop from a musical standpoint.



 

offline Clic on 2002-08-16 07:57 [#00351801]
Points: 5232 Status: Regular | Followup to Clic: #00351798



Mainstream as in the shit they play on MTV.


 

offline kluizenaar from Netherlands Antilles on 2002-08-16 08:53 [#00351888]
Points: 506 Status: Regular




USACID,

a few words to you:

"...samplin is for fools, synthesis is for smarties :0)"

Sorry ,but this is a bullshit statement! You are on a
messageboard dedicated to one of the most talented musicians
in the world , who is a sample-extraordinair.

I agree that just using loops from Diana Ross records, like
that loser puff daddy is very irritating and weak,.but to
just dismiss all the other aspects of sampling with that is
ignorant.

Same for your sweeping generalisation about the whole Hip
Hop community.
I mean taste is a personal thing, but you have lots of
gradations in modern Hip Hop music today. From the Hip Pop
(top 40 rap music) to all the underground artists.



 

offline titsworth from Washington, DC (United States) on 2002-08-16 08:56 [#00351890]
Points: 14550 Status: Lurker



dj shadow, kid koala, kid606, and the avalanches are really
inspiring sample-based artists


 

offline raimons from Stockholm (Sweden) on 2002-08-16 08:59 [#00351892]
Points: 4266 Status: Lurker



use both.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-08-16 09:39 [#00351938]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Show recordbag



What of synthesised mimicry? Like trent singing "bet you
thing this song is about you" on Star****er or Sleeper's
vocal imitation of a beachboy's song on "Nice Guy Eddie", I
often copy sounds from other tracks even thought they're
synthesised from scratch and the tune may be different...


 

offline jand from Braintree (United Kingdom) on 2002-08-16 13:03 [#00352292]
Points: 5975 Status: Moderator | Show recordbag



a load of software synths & modules let you use sample
waveforms as part of the synth....so you can get the best of
both worlds...My old TG500 (2 sy85 plus 1MB RAM sample
memory) lets you do this and transformed that machine for
me...

You can get soem real creative shit that way....


 

offline USACID from Death Valley (Zambia) on 2002-08-19 00:06 [#00354980]
Points: 788 Status: Lurker



u need to chill man, get laid or somethin. A few words?
seemed more like a feature story, but hey...i guess u have a
ton of time on u'r hands...
ps Hiphop should die tomarrow


 

offline diablo on 2002-08-19 00:33 [#00355045]
Points: 3242 Status: Lurker



Hey each to their own eh?

Personally I can dig both the synthetic new shit from
Timbaland and Neptunes and also the sampled genius of, say
Premier, (Gangstarr) etc.

Just relax and enjoy it all, that's what it's there for!


 


Messageboard index