| 
          | 
        
        
         | 
                     
	  |           
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-22 06:00 [#01433606]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
 Not me singing,but the singing melody and all other music  is by me though.
  What do you think? I like it though it´s a little bit odd. It´s not pop, it´s not a lullaby, it´s not a joke, it´s  not a poem, but maybe something in between.
  My first try in this "genre". RobIna - Empty City
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           fat kaimo
             from Finland on 2004-12-22 07:26 [#01433645]
         Points: 2003 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
ok, this is the first thing i hear from you, surprised a bit, it's nice, and it's nice that she sounds  human.. melody = good. 
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-22 13:46 [#01434015]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
thanks, i´ve had a couple of other ideed very different  tracks on the board too, but they all have new versions now  wich I haven´t got the gots to put out again...
 
 
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           tolstoyed
             from the ocean on 2004-12-22 17:01 [#01434245]
         Points: 50073 Status: Moderator
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
come on people...be nice!! it's christmas time.
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           tolstoyed
             from the ocean on 2004-12-22 17:10 [#01434264]
         Points: 50073 Status: Moderator
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
sounds nice! real lovely voice!
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-23 05:26 [#01434788]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
Well, two comments is better than none, thanks and Merry  Christmas!!
 
 
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           r40f
             from qrters tea party on 2004-12-23 11:35 [#01435036]
         Points: 14210 Status: Regular
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
i think that it's a good start, but the melody could use  some work.  i like how it's simple, but it just sort of  follows the chords - it doesn't become very memorable.   also, her phrasing doesn't really flow well.
 
  but again, i enjoyed the minimal production and the lyrics,  and her voice.  all three things work well, imo.  i just  think they need some fine-tuning. 
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-23 12:25 [#01435076]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
well, ivé but some finetuning in it, but maybe it needs  more, not sure about changing the melody tho... 
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-23 13:41 [#01435181]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
wich part of the melody you think needs fixing?
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-23 16:29 [#01435366]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
this is cruel! :.(
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           r40f
             from qrters tea party on 2004-12-23 16:48 [#01435389]
         Points: 14210 Status: Regular
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
easy there...  i just now saw your last question.
  i listened to it again just now.  as i said before, i think  the melody that she sings could be better - mostly in the  second verse, it gets a bit flat-sounding.  she sort of hops  around the octaves, but that's ornamentation of one note and  it doesn't make for an interesting melody.
 
  i think the main problem is her phrasing...  the last part  of the first verse, when she sings the extra "even emptier"  it sort of sounds awkward to me.  the rest of the first  verse is nice - well sung. 
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-23 16:52 [#01435398]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
I won´t get her to sing it agian, but thanks for the  detailed opinion!!! That´s stuff I really appriciate  hearing!! 
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           melack
             from barcielwave on 2004-12-23 16:53 [#01435400]
         Points: 9099 Status: Regular
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
well, nice:)
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-23 17:19 [#01435434]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
is it you or chris clark in you avatar melack?
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
           MrDwatt
             from Helsinki (Finland) on 2004-12-30 09:18 [#01439897]
         Points: 570 Status: Lurker
  | 
| 
 
     
 
   | 
Analords! :P
 
  
         
	  | 
        
        
         | 
           
	  | 
        
        
         
         
Messageboard index 
              
         
	 
	  |