Linux: Advantages/Disadvantages | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
(nobody)
...and 590 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2614087
Today 0
Topics 127542
  
 
Messageboard index
Linux: Advantages/Disadvantages
 

offline sneakattack on 2004-04-16 12:09 [#01146019]
Points: 6049 Status: Lurker



er, I mean, a few comments. I'm retarded


 

offline redrum from the allman brothers band (Ireland) on 2004-04-16 12:10 [#01146022]
Points: 12878 Status: Addict



it's not FOR making music, it's for server use (no matter
what those bastards at redhat and mandrake say)


 

offline sneakattack on 2004-04-16 12:13 [#01146029]
Points: 6049 Status: Lurker | Followup to redrum: #01146022



Hi, when I said I've used it for 10 years, I meant solely,
so all desktop needs satisfied. There definitely are
interesting sound packages, like pd and csound..


 

offline Refund from Melbourne (Australia) on 2004-04-16 15:00 [#01146427]
Points: 7824 Status: Lurker | Followup to Ceri JC: #01145556



on that note..

I'm using a 386 as a dedicated full screen clock in my
loungeroom


 

offline Ganymede from Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius on 2004-04-16 17:58 [#01146593]
Points: 1045 Status: Lurker



Seen on a bumper sticker:

LINUX IS ONLY FREE IF YOUR TIME IS WORTHLESS


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-16 18:06 [#01146596]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular



and for those of you who are unclear on the pronunciation of
linux it is said like:

line-ucks

not lin-ucks as some people seem to mistakenly think.

The reason it is said as line-ucks is because the guy who
created Linux is called Linus Torvalds, and he named with a
word hybridization of UNIX and his name, Linus.

And his name is pronounced line-us


 

offline sneakattack on 2004-04-16 18:11 [#01146598]
Points: 6049 Status: Lurker | Followup to oscillik: #01146596



really bugs me when people get anal about this. What you
are talking about comes from a very old and humorous .au
file (IIRC) you can find on ftp.kernel.org.

anyway, it's been a while. I've met linus; trust me you can
pronounce it lin-ucks. oh and for trivia value, original
title idea was freax


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-16 18:15 [#01146599]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular | Followup to sneakattack: #01146598



i didn't know that the original title was gonna be freax.

some guys in my girlfriend's Music Tech class were talking
about how Linux is crap because it's ancient.

lol!!!!!!!!!!!!



 

offline Refund from Melbourne (Australia) on 2004-04-16 19:50 [#01146668]
Points: 7824 Status: Lurker



I'm beggining to think the anti linux people are just as bad
as the people that push linux...

Linux nerd: "I'm so leet because I use linux"
anti linux geek: "if you use linux we will hate you and call
you stupid for using linux because we hate the linux nerds"

now that I know taht both sides have idiots, I can make a
decision without predjudice

I might just give it a try.....


 

offline qrter from the future, and it works (Netherlands, The) on 2004-04-16 19:55 [#01146671]
Points: 47414 Status: Moderator | Followup to Refund: #01146668



no big surprises there, then.

I mean, this is what happens when you have two camps.


 

offline Refund from Melbourne (Australia) on 2004-04-16 21:45 [#01146717]
Points: 7824 Status: Lurker



http://ftp.redhat.com/

the site says I can download it free from this ftp, but what
exactly am I supposed to download, where is the installer,
and what are the important files?


 

offline Refund from Melbourne (Australia) on 2004-04-17 01:42 [#01146822]
Points: 7824 Status: Lurker



I've been looking into linux faqs for a few hours,.. looks
like hardware is going to be the main bitchs to set up


 

offline sneakattack on 2004-04-17 01:46 [#01146826]
Points: 6049 Status: Lurker | Followup to Refund: #01146822



not true--modern distributions autodetect things very
nicely.

You may be wondering "well how do I know what hardware is
supported and what isn't? I don't have time to wade through
3000 webpages". well there's an easy solution. There's a
bootable CD called 'knoppix', which you can pop into your CD
drive and boots up linux (doesn't use hard drive at all, let
alone install).

I used it recently to take care of my computer when the hard
drive fried. It accessed a USB memory stick, ethernet card,
gfx hardware etc. etc. etc. without me having to do
anything.

anyway, worth checking out--just google for knoppix. I
think 3.2 is the newest version; just d/l and burn. Great
way to check out linux if interested, without hassle of disk
fuckery


 

offline sneakattack on 2004-04-17 01:50 [#01146829]
Points: 6049 Status: Lurker



by the way, if you want up to date redhat, look into 'fedora
core'--that's what you want to get. just snag ISO (cd disc
images), and burn them. the installation is easy. suse and
mandrake are also very easy to use. debian and gentoo are
very popular among developers right now; I use debian.


 

offline Refund from Melbourne (Australia) on 2004-04-17 02:07 [#01146839]
Points: 7824 Status: Lurker | Followup to sneakattack: #01146829



it appears my roomate has a copy of mandrake


 

offline giginger from Milky Beans (United Kingdom) on 2004-04-17 03:24 [#01146862]
Points: 26326 Status: Lurker | Followup to sneakattack: #01146826 | Show recordbag



I've got a vcopy of Knoppix and it boots up well quickly.
Only did it the once though. Could be useful.


 

offline sneakattack on 2004-04-17 03:37 [#01146877]
Points: 6049 Status: Lurker | Followup to giginger: #01146862



it's very useful, but i guess my recommendation was
ignored..


 

offline giginger from Milky Beans (United Kingdom) on 2004-04-17 03:39 [#01146881]
Points: 26326 Status: Lurker | Followup to sneakattack: #01146877 | Show recordbag



I may download it again for my new computer as it's worth
having a backup plan :D


 

offline sneakattack on 2004-04-17 03:44 [#01146882]
Points: 6049 Status: Lurker | Followup to giginger: #01146881



I'm telling you it's a life saver in those situations. and
it can save settings to any removable media, so I was having
it temporarily store session data on the USB ram stick..
very slick.

It also came in handy when I reinstalled debian (when my
hard drive died, a reading head smashed (the laptop fell
hard), and luckily I got all of /home, but lots of /usr was
fucked, so I just reinstalled), the install was missing a
driver for my ethernet card, so I used knoppix to download
and build a kernel and then used that kernel to finish the
install.

I've used lots of rescue discs and CDs but this is a few
orders of magnitude better.


 

offline giginger from Milky Beans (United Kingdom) on 2004-04-17 03:47 [#01146885]
Points: 26326 Status: Lurker | Followup to sneakattack: #01146882 | Show recordbag



Sweweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet!

Def getting the latest copy then :D


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2004-04-17 03:51 [#01146888]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to sneakattack: #01146882 | Show recordbag



Have you used that version that fits on a single floppy disk
(cleverly formatted to 1.7, rather than 1.44) and actually
has loads of recent drivers (most single disk distros have
bare minimum of generic drivers)? I forget the name, but
it's somthing like "Tom Thumb". I know a couple of forensics
people who just use that single disc for all their work and
just save the session data to memory sticks like you said.


 

offline sneakattack on 2004-04-17 04:06 [#01146900]
Points: 6049 Status: Lurker | Followup to Ceri JC: #01146888



I've use tom's 'rtbt' in the past to do shit, but much
prefer a more modern approach like have a business-card
sized disc and a memory stick to do everything. they make
memory stick's large enough to make it really
comfortable--while I was depending on it for 3 days I was
coding using it, and even had tri repetae++ disc 2 and
confield on there, along with the essential session shit =)

there are lots of knoppix based live CDs now.. I think
there's supposed to be a damned good one that is chock full
of forensic tools.. sorry I can't remember it. I bet it's
excellent depending on it 100% like your friends do.

It's really nice using the CD+USB stick combo--you feel
fleet-footed (or something. what the hell am I talking
about?). anyway, it's just nice knowing that you can plug in
anywhere and do your shit.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2004-04-17 04:35 [#01146911]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to sneakattack: #01146900 | Show recordbag



Yeah, that's the one "tom's root boot" something or other
:)

"It's really nice using the CD+USB stick combo--you feel

fleet-footed (or something. what the hell am I talking
about?). anyway, it's just nice knowing that you can plug in

anywhere and do your shit."


Yeah they said they used to take laptops, but it's so much
cooler just turning up with your "gear" in your jacket
pocket!


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 06:50 [#01146946]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular



if you purchase a copy of Linux from a store, they usually
come with a bootable CD filesystem anyways.

and yes, I know what you're all gonna say - "What the fuck
is the point of buying it when you can download it for
free?"

Because if you buy it from a store, in proper packaging, you
get loads of hard copy manuals, and you get support from the
company who made the distribution


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2004-04-17 07:41 [#01146981]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to oscillik: #01146946 | Show recordbag



Yeah support is the main thing, plus until the past few
years (in the uk at least), broadband was so rare that it
was actually cheaper to spend £50 on a boxed copy of linux
rather than £100 worth of phone calls DLing 2/3cd sized
distros ;)

It's worth bearing in mind that the support can be
time-limited from date of purchase (eg 90 days for Definate
Linux), so try to get on the case straight away and not
leave it till you can spare the time (like I did) and let
your support time expire.


 

offline Drunken Mastah from OPPERKLASSESVIN!!! (Norway) on 2004-04-17 07:44 [#01146983]
Points: 35867 Status: Lurker | Followup to oscillik: #01145759 | Show recordbag



Fdisk doesn't detect the linux partition. Don't you think I
tried that?

I found a site that said installing Windows after Linux was
completely possible. I can't seem to find the page again,
though, 'cause Google is suddenly FLOODED with porn sites.


 

offline earthleakage from tell the world you're winning on 2004-04-17 07:44 [#01146985]
Points: 27795 Status: Regular



advantage - not written by microsoft

disadvantage - sounds like something out of a snoopy cartoon


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 07:45 [#01146986]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular | Followup to Ceri JC: #01146981



yeh that's usually the standard, 90 day support.

but at least you get all the manuals in hard copies :)

anyways, you're definitely right about the whole broadband
vs dialup thing....it is better to just download it on a
high speed connection


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 07:45 [#01146988]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular | Followup to Drunken Mastah: #01146983



you're not doing it right

it's not a primary partition, and it's not a DOS extended
partition


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 07:46 [#01146989]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular | Followup to Drunken Mastah: #01146983



and i'm telling you that you CANNOT install Windows after
installing Linux, unless you wanna go fucking around
installing lilo again (the linux bootloader)


 

offline Drunken Mastah from OPPERKLASSESVIN!!! (Norway) on 2004-04-17 07:50 [#01146992]
Points: 35867 Status: Lurker | Followup to oscillik: #01146988 | Show recordbag



Ok, then the site was wrong, and I did something wrong.

How do I get Fdisk to detect the partition, then? I have to
put the HD back into my machine and do it from there.


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 07:51 [#01146994]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular



from fdisk, choose option 3, then choose option 4

that will allow you to delete a Non DOS partition


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 07:52 [#01146996]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular | Followup to Drunken Mastah: #01146992



but make sure that you run

fdisk /mbr

first to get rid of any bootloader in the master boot
record

:)


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 07:53 [#01146998]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular



damn its been a while since i booted up MS-DOS in Virtual
PC!

lol


 

offline Drunken Mastah from OPPERKLASSESVIN!!! (Norway) on 2004-04-17 07:59 [#01147009]
Points: 35867 Status: Lurker | Followup to oscillik: #01146996 | Show recordbag



and that will remove any bootloader in the master
boot-record on that HD, or will that affect my own computer
as well, as I need to do it in that?


 

offline neetta from Finland on 2004-04-17 08:01 [#01147015]
Points: 5924 Status: Regular



if i had an internet connection on my home pc i'd have
linux, but since i haven't i use win xp (games <3 )

but i'd prefer os x to both of them


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 08:17 [#01147035]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular | Followup to Drunken Mastah: #01147009



ooh, wait

don't do fdisk /mbr on your own hard drive

put the hard drive that has linux on, back into your bros
case and use a boot up floppy disk and use fdisk from that

no you're right - you don't wanna delete your own mbr

sorry i hadn't clarified that


 

offline Drunken Mastah from OPPERKLASSESVIN!!! (Norway) on 2004-04-17 09:32 [#01147106]
Points: 35867 Status: Lurker | Followup to oscillik: #01147035 | Show recordbag



ah, but that´s one of the problems: boot disks doesn´t
work when the HD is in that computer. Not windows/dos, nor
linux. Only get "I/O error," so I have to do it from my own
computer. I´m trying to access it through a friends machine
(a portable mac and using ssh), so that I can backup
everything and delete the linux partition. The problem is
that I have to set-up a ftp-server on my computer and then
we have to ssh into it and hope that the linux-files will
show up.

if not I´ll have to remove the partition without backup,
but will it be a problem if I don´t remove the mbr? Is that
something that is connected to the computer instead if the
HD itself?


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 09:42 [#01147120]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular | Followup to Drunken Mastah: #01147106



basically the MBR is the part of the hard drive that has the
boot loader for your operating system.

If you have a Windows system, the Windows boot loader will
be in the MBR. If you have installed a Linux system, there
will be lilo.

If you're getting I/O error on your bros computer, either
his floppy drive is knackered, or the boot disk is.

You could try just getting rid of the Linux partition on the
hard drive (using fdisk in the usual way to get rid of a
partition) and then try installing windows on the entire
drive - I'm not too sure if Windows will overwrite whatever
MBR is there, hopefully it will :)

By the way, when you type "fdisk /mbr" there is no output
from that command - in other words, it doesn't say something
like "MBR Restored" or something like that, ok?


 

offline Drunken Mastah from OPPERKLASSESVIN!!! (Norway) on 2004-04-17 10:26 [#01147173]
Points: 35867 Status: Lurker | Followup to oscillik: #01147120 | Show recordbag



yeah, well, I need to backup my brothers files first. There
are some important stuff in there.

We tried using ftp, but that didn't work, so now we're going
to try SSH. Hopefully, the server/client won't care if the
filesystem is linux or windows. If not, my brothers files
will be lost.

nah, the diskette-station isn't broke either.. it says I/O
error with the cdrom and the dvdstation as well, and I know
they work.


 

offline Drunken Mastah from OPPERKLASSESVIN!!! (Norway) on 2004-04-17 15:28 [#01147545]
Points: 35867 Status: Lurker | Show recordbag



ah! fuckin' fixed it!

had to do some debug-shit in dos. had to write some lines..
just like on the good ol' commodore64! Finally this shit is
off my (brothers) computer!


 

offline w M w from London (United Kingdom) on 2004-04-17 17:22 [#01147671]
Points: 21452 Status: Lurker



I just got a used computer I bought with no operating
installed on it (apparently it's illegal to sell used
computers with operating systems or something). Well on a
label on the computer it says "designed for windows 98/nt".
I guess that's a fact since when trying to install windows
95 (the only one I have now), scandisk made me change lots
and lots of file names (maybe w95 uses some different naming
format or something) and after finally doing that, it didn't
work.


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 17:25 [#01147676]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular



that "Designed for Windows 98/NT" sticker has bugger all to
do with the hard drive inside the machine - it's talking
about the graphics card, sound card, motherboard, any NIC's
that are on you ISA or PCI bus.

if you bought it with no operating system on the machine,
there wouldn't be any files on the hard drive at all,
therefore scandisk wouldn't be able to find any files to
change.

something weird is going on there mate


 

offline Sanguine from San Francisco (United States) on 2004-04-17 18:14 [#01147722]
Points: 859 Status: Lurker



Advantages:

- Stable. VERY stable.
- Highly customizable
- Open source programs all over the place, for free
- Very powerful standard tools for development
- Geek points

Disadvantages:

- Takes an enormous time to learn
- Takes a lot of time troubleshooting problems
- Takes a lot of damn time...

There are tons of music programs out there for Linux, just
not the standard one's you're used to. Well, except Final
Scratch... and I'd imagine some of the mac specific music
programs can be ported over somehow.

Anywho, troubleshooting problems in linux can be a
nightmare. You can, without a whole lot of effort, screw
your system up beyond repair and need to reinstall. That
being said though, you CAN fix the problems by yourself,
which you can't really do in windows (where you just reboot
and pray). It's incredibly rewarding to get the computer
working again.

Lately though the OS has become much more user friendly,
especially the installation process. You get a pretty much
default setup right out of the box and can customize it
quite nicely to fit your needs and your system (kernel
compiling is a pain in the ass, but well worth the effort in
my opinion).

Just decide how much time you can devote to learning it and
if that time would be better spent learning more about the
music programs you already have


 

offline oscillik from the fires of orc on 2004-04-17 18:46 [#01147770]
Points: 7746 Status: Regular | Followup to Sanguine: #01147722



about porting Mac music programs to Linux, it'd be
impossible - they either use Cocoa or Carbon libraries -
either way, they're Macintosh specific and aren't available
for any other operating system except Macintosh.

and also Linux files don't have metadata like Mac files do

:)


 

offline w M w from London (United Kingdom) on 2004-04-17 19:14 [#01147781]
Points: 21452 Status: Lurker | Followup to oscillik: #01147676



I have very little know how, yet am trying to wing it.
Here's what happened so far: made bios start from drive a,
turned it on and used boot disk, tried to "setup" win95 but
it said I need some partition or something, so actually
managed to get fdisk to work (whadaya know, just type
"fdisk") and made a "primary dos partition" that was 9782
Mbytes, tried "setup" win95 again but prompted I needed more
bytes or some shit.. so I took a wild guess and and tried
"format c:".. I guess there was stuff on it cuz it formated
stuff, finally "setup"win95 worked now (I guess enough bytes
were free from the format or soemthing), then... hmm oh
yeah, scandisk started checking stuff and added stuff I
thought I needed, apparently it started scanning over
because of the additions but then prompted to rename a bunch
of the files (like 300 of them- I had to hit "f" for fix for
every one (I positioned a book on a marker over the f key
and let it go)).. um, there was one error it couldn't fix-
some windows naming error or something, then it started the
win95 setup (the mouse started working), then it prompted
that there was some reason it couldn't work I forget what.

Ta daaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!

That was very interesting huh?


 


Messageboard index