YOUR TOP 5 DRUMMERS | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
(nobody)
...and 184 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2613408
Today 0
Topics 127499
  
 
Messageboard index
YOUR TOP 5 DRUMMERS
 

Quoth from Lincoln on 2001-11-20 02:54 [#00053691]



05: Peter Erskine
04: Chad Sexton
03: Danny Carey
02: Buddy Rich
01: John Bonham


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 02:57 [#00053692]



5) Ginger Baker
4) Bill Ward
3) Ringo Star
2) John Bonham
1) Keith Moon


 

Quoth from Lincoln on 2001-11-20 02:58 [#00053694]



holy shit... I forgot BAKER!! Fucking rocks!... good choice
Ophecks.. but come on, Ringo??? WTF


 

The_Funkmaster from Newfoundland, Canada on 2001-11-20 03:02 [#00053698]



1. Neil Peart
2. Phil Collins
3. Buddy from Dave Matthews Band
4. John Bonham
5. Hmmm, well Tool's drummer impressed me with the album
Lateralus... so I'll say him for number 5...



 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 03:14 [#00053702]



Ringo is a member of the greatest band, no, actually THE
GREATEST ACCOMPLISHMENT IN HUMAN HISTORY, The Beatles. That
ALONE gets him on there! He's perfect! If Baker or Moon or
some showoff got in that band, then the chemistry would be
ruined. It was a joint effort, not an instrumental
show-off-fest, and Ringo held down the fort.
GO RINGO!!!! Don't let anyone mock you, you were a Beatles
and the rest of those nobody-wannabes WEREN'T!!!


 

Aron? from Canada on 2001-11-20 03:15 [#00053704]



uhhh
the guy form the roots
then
the guy from pizzicato five

??


 

The_Funkmaster from Newfoundland, Canada on 2001-11-20 03:19 [#00053708]



How could no one else say Neil Peart? He is friggin
amazing!!!!! I have yet to hear a drummer better...

also, I have to say that I find Keith Moon annoying... when
I listen to The Who, all I can hear half the time is the
damn drumming... there is a time for loud drumming, and a
time for quiet... I just feel he is annoying... he has the
skill though...


 

The_Funkmaster from Newfoundland, Canada on 2001-11-20 03:22 [#00053709]



Nah, Ringo Starr is nothing big... it's not like the songs
the beatles wrote took such technical skill on the drumms...
plus, it was Mcartney and Lennon who wrote most of the
songs, and then Harrison threw in a few... I get by with a
little help from my friends is far from the best beatles
song... so no, he's definately not the best drummer, far
from it... The Beatles made Ringo Starr, so in other words,
Lennon and Mcartney made Ringo Starr...


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 03:24 [#00053711]



Ringo, baby, it's all Ringo. The proof is in the pudding, he
played drums on the songs that everybody else WANTED to play
drums on...
but guess what...
EVERYBODY ELSE WASN'T A BEATLE, YOU DIG?!?!?!?!
Sunshine of Your Love my ass. Pinball Wizard, suck my dick.
Cheesy prog Peart, git off da stage, little boy!!! John
Bonham? More like John Bone-him, cuz he's gay. Strawberry
Fields Forever is the REAL prize, and RINGO WINS FIRST
PLACE!!!!


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 03:26 [#00053713]



Ringo is the man. Complimeted them perfectly. It wasn't
about technical skill, it was about Lennon/Mac's
imaginations and ideas, and Ringo smartly stayed in the
background, delivering tasteful beats that only added to the
pop nirvana.


 

The_Funkmaster from Newfoundland, Canada on 2001-11-20 03:27 [#00053714]



yeah, I must admit, a lot of Rush tunes (well the 80's stuff
at least) is pretty crappy, but the drumming is excellent...
well, every instrument is played excellent... Geddy Lee is
my favorite bass player by the way... I have a Rush live
album Three Stages, and the drum solo is excellent...


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 03:27 [#00053715]



Keith needed to stay in the background, the show-off wanker.

The way I'm going on, you'd think I WAS Ringo.


 

g on 2001-11-20 03:37 [#00053718]



jimmy chamberlain


 

Quoth from Lincoln on 2001-11-20 04:15 [#00053726]



Ophecks... Ringo has no style... all of his drum beats were
what George Martin told him to do. I strongly urge that you
listen to more drummers than that of maybe the greatest
rock'n roll band of all time. For fucks sake, Gene Krupa or
Buddy Rich certainly aren't "show-off's" ... that's their
style of music. Would you call Miles Davis, or Armstrong a
show off just b/c they play jazz? I'm tired of Ringo playing
2 & 4 shit.


 

popwilleatitse1f from Vancouver Canada on 2001-11-20 04:18 [#00053727]



1. Jimmy Chamberlin
2. Danny Carey
3. who cares about the rest these two guys are the shit.


 

Clobe Smith from over here on 2001-11-20 04:44 [#00053735]



nick mason
john bonham
phil selway
that guy from dave mathews band

can't think of anyone else. and ophecks, thanks for
standing up for ringo. without him, who sings good night,
good night?



 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 05:16 [#00053739]



Bitches are all just jealous that RINGO was in the greatest
human achievement. I forgot Phil Selway, boot Ginger out of
my list then.


 

fesldek on 2001-11-20 05:18 [#00053740]



01: Me drumming my nuts against your chin


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 05:19 [#00053741]



Good choice.



 

mONGOLOIDmORON on 2001-11-20 05:21 [#00053745]



indeed


 

T®ansmission from Netherlands...YEAH! EAT GRASS!! on 2001-11-20 06:28 [#00053747]



Tomas Haake
Raymond Herrera

No one can beat them....


 

T®ansmission from Netherlands...YEAH! EAT GRASS!! on 2001-11-20 06:33 [#00053748]



Tomas Haake
Raymond Herrera

No one can beat them....


 

ola the jangler from sollentuna fish on 2001-11-20 07:22 [#00053755]



1. that guy in "biohazard"
he has got the soul man


 

Mutant Death Pengwin from Medicine Hat on 2001-11-20 09:25 [#00053768]



dino whatever from fear factory
the drummer morbid angel
and the drummer from mortician is funny
and the drummer from enslaved is fucking amazing
all metal, but metal has the most talented drummers and
guitarists!


 

Fernz on 2001-11-20 09:55 [#00053778]



Phil Selway
Keith Moon
Jimmy Chamberlain
John Bonham
Dave Grohl

Fan-fuckin-tastic I say. :)


 

phiz from Amsterdam on 2001-11-20 10:13 [#00053788]



Jon Bonham
Kieth Moon
fella out the Police
Gene Kruppa
Animal


 

balthus from europe on 2001-11-20 10:35 [#00053796]



1. paul motian
2. steve reich
3. tony williams (for herbie hancock)
4. plus bob becker, russel hartenberger, garry kvistad and
james preiss (for steve reich)
5. is dave abbruzzese the guy who is drumming on pearl jam's
'yield'?


 

Rob.E. from London on 2001-11-20 11:01 [#00053799]



Steve Morris(New Order) ,Loz(Ride),Ringo(him again),those 2
drummers from Sigue S.Sputnik. I love u all. }:>



 

The kize from glasgow on 2001-11-20 11:34 [#00053806]



909 what a drummer


 

Murray from England on 2001-11-20 14:59 [#00053836]



1) Joey Jordoson
2)Liam Howlett
3) the guy from Korn
4)
5)Monkey.....MONKEY DRUMMER, anybody who can drum to Mt
Saint Micheal + ST Micheals Mount is the man
Maybe he should have come first :S


 

T®ansmission from Netherlands on 2001-11-20 15:51 [#00053843]



Mutant Death Pengwin :

That DINO guy is the guitar player, Raymond is the drummer
;)

Check them out at the best fansite
online...http://www.digimortal.net


 

Mutant Death Pengwin from Medicine Hat on 2001-11-20 18:27 [#00053888]



i stopped listening to metal years ago, so i kinda forgot
whos who of metal.


 

GEMMA PATTERSON on 2001-11-20 19:49 [#00053900]



I liked the drummer that plays in the band Aphex Twin...
he's great!!!


 

f.l.e.a from doghole on 2001-11-20 20:01 [#00053911]



1.Akira Jimbo
2.Akira Jimbo
3.Akira Jimbo
4.Akira Jimbo
5.cEVIN kEY


 

laughing cow from willow farm on 2001-11-20 21:35 [#00053966]



Boss Tr 909
Boss Tr 505
The drummer from flaming lips
Mathew's golden turkey drummers
Phil Collins is APPALING!, how can you like him???


 

RaYn from Dirty T, AZ USA on 2001-11-20 21:54 [#00053984]



Alright HERE--drummers that rule in no particular order:
John Bonham, Danny Carey, Buddy Rich, Jack DeJohnette,
Billy Cobham. BOOM.


 

crayon_kid from the sewers under your house on 2001-11-20 22:37 [#00054025]



1danny carrey of tool
2ginger fish of marilyn manson
3will rieflin of kmfdm
4will rieflin of ministry
5the monkeydrummer


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 22:41 [#00054027]



Ringo Starr, you stupid cunts. WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH
YOU? WHEN KMFDM AND CREAM AND THE SMASHING PUMPKINS ARE
FORGOTTEN AND ROTTING AWAY IN THE GROUND, THE BEATLES WILL
STILL BE REVERED, AND RINGO WILL STILL BE THE BEST!!!!


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 22:42 [#00054028]



LOL at Gemma Patterson's post, haha.


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-20 22:42 [#00054029]



I missed ya babe, where ya been?


 

crayon_kid from the sewers under your house on 2001-11-21 02:02 [#00054046]



stop spazzing ophecks. ringo is good, but not revolutionary.
the beatles were a band. and there lyrics far outdid the
drumming of the ugliest brit the world has everdone.
they had good vocals. but only decent drumming.


 

crayon_kid from the sewers under your house on 2001-11-21 02:03 [#00054047]



oops i meant the ugliest brit the world has ever 'known'.



 

The kize from glasgow on 2001-11-21 02:23 [#00054052]



arrrrrghgghhgg fuuuuuuuuuck drummers who cares????? jesus!


 

crayon_kid from the sewers under your house on 2001-11-21 02:26 [#00054054]



fuck you kize.
the damn topic will slide if you dont answer it. you just
brought it back to the top, moron.
oh and post some of YOUR music. i could use a good laugh.


 

Quoth from Lincoln on 2001-11-21 02:53 [#00054059]



ouch... Kize: w/out drumming, Your little person that is
known as The Aphex Twin, WOULD NOT exist. PERIOD.
OPHECKS: Ringo would not have been famous, if not for his
producer (one of the greatest) George Martin.


 

Spanky Pentweeter from In da bowels of da oith on 2001-11-21 09:37 [#00054097]



1) Terry Bozzio
2) Neil Peart
3) Bill Bruford
4)Phil Collins/Chester Thompson (Genesis live pairing)
5) Pierre Moerlin

Very proggy selection there, but these fusion drummers were
drummin' some crazy timed shit...and with finesse I might
add


 

ola the jangler from sollentuna fish on 2001-11-21 10:08 [#00054102]



okay! the drummer from fera factory is good! but the best
drummers around is really those guys who plays the jazz
thing...

weezer are great to!
thank you.


 

jedy from ireland on 2001-11-21 11:11 [#00054111]



Bill Bruford
Stewart Copeland
phil collins
Pat Mastelotto



 

The_Funkmaster from Newfoundland, Canada on 2001-11-21 15:46 [#00054186]



Anyone who says Phil Collins sucks is an idiot... maybe his
pop music sucks, but him as a drummer, he's awesome... very
subtle in my opinion, but great...


 

Ophecks from Nova Scotia on 2001-11-21 18:29 [#00054228]



Ringo is pure awesomeness, rolled into a 5'6'' body and a
huge nose. He's the man, HE'S the drummer that will go down
in eternity while all others are forgotten, end of story.
The reality is, he IS famous, there's no if's and's or
but's.


 


Messageboard index