Dumb Techno vs. Intelligent Techno | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
(nobody)
...and 182 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2613408
Today 0
Topics 127499
  
 
Messageboard index
Dumb Techno vs. Intelligent Techno
 

Underwear Model on 2001-11-08 00:39 [#00049552]



Dudes, whats the matter with IDM ? IDM stands for
INTELLIGENT DANCE MUSIC, so does that mean that regular
DANCE music is "dumb" !? What the hell, Ive gotz lots dumb
Techno 4/4 140 BPM Loop Techno records, and I really like
em', its nothing to be ashamed of......I say ONE LOVE, but
not to teh TRANCE fans, hehehehe


 

paperclip on 2001-11-08 00:42 [#00049553]



fuck trance..
thats bullshit


 

Xanatos from NYC on 2001-11-08 00:59 [#00049554]



I like the term IDM, because I don't like to associate Aphex
etc. with other techno music. When I tell people I listen
to electronica they say "oh you mean like techno music", and
really, its a completely different thing. Regardless of
whether or not one is more "intelligent" than the other; it
is clearly a different catagory of music. When I tell
people I listen to IDM they have no idea what I'm talking
about, and that's how it should be, because most of them
have never heard any of it.

It is also pretty clear that although they are both Techno,
what most of us here consider IDM usually appeals to
tastes more sophisticated in electronic music. Hence, it is
pretty easy to get into the groove of crap club dance music,
but it takes a little more listening and experience to
really get into aphex and other "IDM"


 

One Less Turnip from The Lighter Side of Telemarketing on 2001-11-08 01:00 [#00049555]



Yes, dumb techno sucks balls

Dancing is foolish...

Nothin' like a little Funker Vogt


 

od from perth on 2001-11-08 01:02 [#00049556]



dance is "dumb" coz it repeats, its piss easy to listen to
and is (comparatively and generally) simple and cliched to
make.
this doesnt necesarily (sp?) mena its bad, however.

BTW this is how I see it, anyway


 

drugiebowzer from uoyoutland on 2001-11-08 01:04 [#00049557]



"Fuck trance...that;s bullshit"...what an ignorant cock you
must be :-(

The guy mentioned 4/4 beats so you go ahead and jump the
gun, generalising everything that happens to contain a 4.4
beat as "trance" bollocks..dig a little beneath the suger
coated vacuos, sanitised pop gloss versions of 4.4 dance and
you will be pleased to find an as yet undiscovered world of
artistically valid and quite enlightening music forms:-p

Examples of "4.4 trance bollocks you might like---jeff
mills, dave clarke, carl craig, plastikman, regis, surgeon,
dj hell, international deejay gigolos, ian pooley, lucien
foort, secret cinema, dj skull, robert hood, UR, red planet,
drexciya, ,masters at work, felix da housecat, aphrohead, dj
sneak, green velvet, boo williams, dj rush, dj funk, orlando
voorn, marshall jeferson, thomas chrome, sven vath, laurent
garnier, derrick may,.....etcetcetcetc\\\\\\


 

drugiebowzer from uoyoutland on 2001-11-08 01:07 [#00049558]



Why is techno music dumb? Because of its simplicity and
minimalism? Oh well in that case you can discard alot of
the new aphex album for being "dumbass" also :-p.....and
what's so novel about dancing ?...I personally find it
pretty fucking enjoyable actually:-p


 

Underwear model on 2001-11-08 01:09 [#00049559]



So you only listen to IDM cuz it isnt so easy to get into
to, and DANCE music is in generally dumb ? Isnt that a lil
bit contradicting ? I mean stuff like the BEATLES anddd
(those bands that play real instruments) Beethoven are also
very easy to listen to ? So does that mean their stuff is
dumb or not complex enuff, and therfor bAD ?


 

Nostromo Nonentity from the center of the sun on 2001-11-08 01:16 [#00049561]



Dancing is disrespectful


 

Xanatos from NYC on 2001-11-08 01:16 [#00049562]



Here's the point:

I say, hey (random person), I like techno music. Could you
play me some techno music you think I would like?

He will play me some crap which I will hate. So it doesn't
quite define it does it?


 

paperclip on 2001-11-08 01:16 [#00049564]



the people who make this music are complete fucking
idiots..
fucking euro trash.
hit a couple of keys, make up some bullshit melody, put a
big beat to it and there you have it.
complete.
:)


 

od from perth on 2001-11-08 01:25 [#00049567]



its my fuckin opinion, grow up.

i barely listen to idm anyway so go cry to someone else.


 

Xanatos from NYC on 2001-11-08 01:25 [#00049568]



od what do you listen to?


 

drugiebowzer from uoyoutland on 2001-11-08 01:26 [#00049569]



Paperclip....thanks man, haha...you've cheered me up no
end:-)....


 

od from perth on 2001-11-08 01:30 [#00049571]



i listen to - techno :)
just simple stuff
prodigy and chemical brothers and rubbish liek that that
most ppl here arent into.

only idm ive evere heard is afx and squarepusher and tri
repetae by autechre.
i kid you not


 

joey the greek on 2001-11-08 01:33 [#00049572]



I love most of the list of techno you said before....It's
wierd nobody talks about those artists, all that chicago
style rocks!!! Relief records are amazing!!


 

paperclip on 2001-11-08 01:34 [#00049573]



hey drugiebowzer..
suck my balls.
:)
fucking raver trash.


 

Underwear model on 2001-11-08 01:35 [#00049574]



we are talking about TECHNO and not TRANCE ! RIGHT ! Did you
get that ?!


 

Tundra Boy from Antarctica on 2001-11-08 01:35 [#00049575]



Friends stand by each other in thick and thin


 

joey the greek on 2001-11-08 01:37 [#00049576]



They're mostly americans on that list you stupid prick
paperclip. Eurotrash?


 

paperclip on 2001-11-08 01:39 [#00049577]



i wasnt refering to his list you cocksucker


 

joey the greek on 2001-11-08 01:41 [#00049579]



What the fuck are you talking about? Look, just be CLEAR
and maybe you won't look so stupid??


 

paperclip on 2001-11-08 01:43 [#00049580]



im afraid its not me whos looking stupid here..
your the ass whos been jumping to stupid conclusions.


 

joey the greek on 2001-11-08 01:44 [#00049581]



The list is mostly Americans, You're a Prick, that's just
the truth, I was stating a fact.


 

paperclip on 2001-11-08 01:46 [#00049582]



i wasnt talking about the list.



 

joey the greek on 2001-11-08 01:47 [#00049583]



but you agree you're a prick?


 

The_Funkmaster from Newfoundland, Canada on 2001-11-08 01:49 [#00049584]



well, if the length of time to get into a type of electronic
music differentiates it as either IDM, or dumb ass dance
music, well here's an interesting thing... I bought In Sides
by Orbital back in April or so (my first pure electronic
album) and I'm just now starting to really get into it... I
bought I Care Because You Do, and the RDJ album, and in a
week I thought they were the 2nd best thing ever (sliced
bread still gets my #1 vote)... Now, I'm not saying Orbital
is easy music to get into, just that it's closer to "dumb"
dance music then Aphex Twin, and say Autechre... but
anyways, the reason pure dance music gets a bad rap, is
because most of it probably is slapped together to make
money... like someone said, you get a beat, loop it, and
stick in a catchy melody... I'm not saying it all is, cause
there is plenty of dance music I like, but most of it
probably is...


 

paperclip on 2001-11-08 01:51 [#00049585]



not exactly..
in fact, id go as far as to say that your a dumbass faggot.
ive been talking about dumb techno y'know, what this topic
is about..
then you come out of left field with your fucking hand down
your pants jacking off to a picture of your own mother..



 

The_Funkmaster from Newfoundland, Canada on 2001-11-08 01:51 [#00049586]



but hey, if you like the music, who cares? IDM is just a
marketing label, and music labels are stupid...


 

The_Funkmaster from Newfoundland, Canada on 2001-11-08 01:53 [#00049587]



Oh, and by the way, Adnans by Orbital is an awesome song!!!
:)


 

paperclip on 2001-11-08 02:04 [#00049589]



and "Adelante" by Sash!..
thats a fucking wicked track.
;)


 

drugiebowzer from uoyoutland on 2001-11-08 02:37 [#00049591]



Joey, nice one..and Funkmaster, if I remember correctly
Orbital back in the day were actually labelled a part of the
rave culture here in the UK, the Brown album is very
representative of that time in sound..another sidenote,
Universal Indicator was made in response to the said artists
I stated above....so no Pimplife or whoever was just
emphasising his general ignorance b4...you can eat MY
Balls:-p


 

drugiebowzer from uoyoutland on 2001-11-08 02:39 [#00049592]



PS- Would you label Mike Dredd "eurotrash"?..He is German
after all, and he is prone to the odd banging acid track:-p


 

Pimplife on 2001-11-08 02:40 [#00049593]



i would if they wernt already in your mothers mouth.
;)


 

drugiebowzer from uoyoutland on 2001-11-08 02:43 [#00049594]



your dumb:-p..but I like your simplicity....heh.


 

Pimplife on 2001-11-08 02:46 [#00049595]



aww..
thanks man.
and i like the fact that your a retard.
;)


 

drugiebowzer from uoyoutland on 2001-11-08 02:50 [#00049596]



I like the fact you have an anal fixation and a mother
complex :-)...takes all sorts eh?...heh....alright I'm
done..shut up.:-(...don't like arguing with clueless angst
ridden self hating non entities like yourself ....goodbye,
glad I'm not you..


 

Pimplife on 2001-11-08 02:55 [#00049598]



oright..
make sure to mention my name next time your mother is
gobbling on your nuts.. do it for me..
cheers
;)


 

Aktium from bat country on 2001-11-08 03:04 [#00049600]



in sides by orbital are amazing. the last 2 albums by them
arn't that good.


 

mu-ziq on 2001-11-08 03:08 [#00049604]



Dance, dumb techno is the shittiest music.Trance is fucking
gay too. Richard D. James is intelligent electronica.
Musically, he is a genius with his fucked up rhythms and
crazy voices. The beats are fucking rad.


 

mu-ziq on 2001-11-08 03:09 [#00049605]



Dance, dumb techno is the shittiest music.Trance is fucking
gay too. Richard D. James is intelligent electronica.
Musically, he is a genius with his fucked up rhythms and
crazy voices. The beats are fucking rad.


 

drugiebowzer on 2001-11-08 03:19 [#00049609]



i take back everything i said!
Pimplife.. your my god, i wish you would let me suck YOUR
balls..
*sigh*



 

drugiebowzer on 2001-11-08 03:20 [#00049610]



is it too late to make it up to you?
can we be friends?


 

Pimplife on 2001-11-08 03:22 [#00049612]



im afraid its too late for that..
i might still let you suck my balls though.
would you let me think about it?


 

ervon erbot on 2001-11-08 03:56 [#00049617]



kaiser salsek by goldie has some fucken ace drums.

that is for goldie who you know, is a bit of a cheese
master- i am quite impressed.

i think the best way to equate intelligence or the level of
intelligence to dance music is to apply rich's explanation
of brain dance. it is music if were to dance to would make
you look like you were having a seizure or so - so you don't
instead have to 'process' let it out in your head. And so -
the more you have to like use your head the more
intelligent.

regular bd oh bd oh bd oh @ 140/120bpm isn't all that hard
to like process let alone dance too - just a shame it is so
boring and uninspiring.



 

Marzipan Dolphin from Atlantis on 2001-11-08 05:08 [#00049624]



to druggiebowzer
um..I know yer hearts in the right place but your post is
somewhat misleading...
most of the artists you have mentioned below and especially
jeff mills, carl craig, dj hell, dj skull, surgeon,
plastickman, drexicya, laurent garnier (his last album is
IDM in my book..awesome stuff) are all the finest examples
of techno/detroit techno/ borderline house...but not
trance..but I agree with you that a lot of intelligence
crept into the techno scene while people weren't looking,
Cristian Vogel, Neil Landstrumm, Tobias Schmidt etc all have
their roots in techno but their later stuff can stand in
their own right as far as intelligence and creativity as in
comparison to any IDM, infact in some cases it's even more
commendable that at the bottom of all the wirggly, knob
twidly weirdness they throw into their stuff..there's still
a solid 4/4 backbone albiet stretched to the limits of
recognition...

Examples of "4.4 trance bollocks you might like---jeff
mills, dave clarke, carl craig, plastikman, regis, surgeon,
dj hell, international deejay gigolos, ian pooley, lucien
foort, secret cinema, dj skull, robert hood, UR, red planet,
drexciya, ,masters at work, felix da housecat, aphrohead, dj
sneak, green velvet, boo williams, dj rush, dj funk, orlando
voorn, marshall jeferson, thomas chrome, sven vath, laurent
garnier, derrick may,.....


 

Mylanta Jones on 2001-11-08 05:18 [#00049627]



aww maw goowd nees...
MR MylantA fins it funny...in a seeminglesss harmless
topic of a thread..you people find it necessary to utter the
word FAGGOT...14 times...how wonDERful..why not use the
word..HOmoSEXUal? or ass pirate....maybe fudge
packer?...maybe get old school..and say doing of mens
ASSES...or NOT a DOER Of CUnts....but why faggot..its
so..passe....
Oh..Im sorry..were you refering to "a bundle of sticks"
the original meaning of the word? or maybe you
meant...cigarrettes??
trance may not be the most complex or original type of
modern "techno"..but at one time..it was cutting
edge....remember that..the next time you are getting a penis
shoved up your dialated asshole... :)


 

Pimplife on 2001-11-08 05:26 [#00049631]



14 times..
more like once you assgobbler


 

Pimplife on 2001-11-08 05:32 [#00049632]



hey, look at me! im a stupid faggot!!



 

Pimplife on 2001-11-08 05:35 [#00049633]



HEY!! that wasnt me!
someones logging in as me..
you motherfucker.


 


Messageboard index