moral conflict | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
Now online (1)
ijonspeches
...and 170 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2613457
Today 3
Topics 127500
  
 
Messageboard index
moral conflict
 

ross from Canada on 2001-04-01 02:03 [#00002213]



I have over 100 cds that ive got over the past 2 years, but
one way or another ive gotten 1 or 2 burns for some reason.
Here's the story: awhile ago my friend found a burn of
richard d james album, so i had access to a friends burner,
and currently did have money so i burnt it *owch* recently
i broke the burnt copy, because i felt this as a big
injustice to the work of Richard. I also through a similar
process got a copy of shadows pre-emptive strike, i own
endtroducing by buying it, but i feel morally bad for
this..So my question is..if you have bought about a 100 with
your own money, is it bad to have a burn or two..i feel
right now, having full cds burnt is terrible..so should i
break my pre-emptive strike? and just buy it soon (im really
short on money though, saving up for other cds) I feel
morally confused


 

ross from Canada on 2001-04-01 02:08 [#00002216]



Why is there 2 of these topics? aaa...i meant 'didnt have
money currently' in the first part


 

AFXDUB from canada on 2001-04-01 04:35 [#00002224]



hmm... well i have burnt many many many cds and aphex twin
and his other aliases are among those, heres what it comes
down to plain and simple: i buy what i can of his, and ive
even ordered his two videos "windowlicker" and "come to
viddy". i buy everything i can of his, and not shit online
because its far far too expensive and is not in my price
range. so i burn what i cab't buy. and now i have all the
afx stuff. and i feel damn good about it.


 

XePhA88 from San Jose, CA on 2001-04-01 07:53 [#00002227]



here's my angle really quick. always keep in mind that
economy is simply a means to an end. i.e. that it is here
so that we can exist in large numbers of population, and be
able to get the necessary work done. money acts as a
motivational force in order to get everyone to work.
personally i think that ART should have no place in a system
like this, because it can lead to the corruption of that
Art. thus, rip away to your hearts content. only start to
question your actions when you see musical artist you
support start to go broke. don't you think it would be a
better thing for you to copy a cd, and give the money that
would have spent to a charity?

also, this whole mp3 thing is making the economic world
realize that media is no long constrained to physical
realms. a song can just be a 0 or a 1 on your hard
drive.... of which can be duplicated infinitely. One day we
will have to pay for napster, and personally i support that.
i'd rather pay 5 bucks a month to get all the music i want
than pay 15 bucks for a cd with a few songs that i want from
it. ... but that's just my angle.


 

XePhA88 from San Jose, CA on 2001-04-01 07:53 [#00002228]



ok, not so quick... sorry


 

ross from Canada on 2001-04-01 08:52 [#00002229]



thankyou Guys...yeah art, to me, i make music and cds, and i
will for the most part give them out for free, because i'm
not going to charge people. Id rather have them know it
comes from my love for music, than a need for money.


 

AFXDUB from Canada on 2001-04-01 10:04 [#00002232]



ross: totally. i make some tracks here and there and tons of
art shit on my comp/by hand then into the computer and i
always give it away or give it for another form of music or
art by someone else... i like to think of it as sharing of
peoples art that expresses themselves. that shits great...
iam all for iT!


 

ross from Canada on 2001-04-01 20:49 [#00002277]



great! I can look at this with a much better view now..much
appreciated everyone


 

XePhA88 from San Jose, CA on 2001-04-02 00:17 [#00002288]



yeah ross, go for it. spread the love!


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-04-25 17:28 [#00193831]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to XePhA88: #00002227 | Show recordbag



I've often thought about the piracy/charity thing, but
really you are effectively really making the manufacturer of
whatever you are pirating "donate" their profits without
consent.

Mind you, I have a custom burn of "BoC rarities" which
consist solely of discontinued tracks and I don't see
anything wrong with that.


 


Messageboard index