Messageboard index
|
|
Israel-Palestine Debate: Finkelstein, Destiny, M. Rabbani &
Benny Morris | Lex Fridman Podcast #418
|
|
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-16 22:50 [#02633568]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Show recordbag
|
|
LAZY_TITLE
/r/chomsky thread: LAZY_TITLE
/r/stupidpol thread: LAZY_TITLE
i haven't watched this yet, but i understand there's a lot of knowledge here, with three scholars (and not from the monkey twitch streamer), that are all over the spectrum, including a bonafide zionist
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-16 23:00 [#02633569]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Show recordbag
|
|
stupidpol sure likes to call destiny 'cuck', i'm sure in some double irony way (i don't stupidpol, but the takes i read were decent)
|
|
Tony Danza
from NAFO Suicide Hotline on 2024-03-17 18:31 [#02633583]
Points: 3647 Status: Regular
|
|
no
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-17 20:17 [#02633587]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to Tony Danza: #02633583 | Show recordbag
|
|
it's about the other guys! (also finkelstein rips the streamer several new ones)
|
|
belb
from mmmmmmhhhhzzzz!!! on 2024-03-17 20:58 [#02633589]
Points: 6385 Status: Lurker
|
|
isn't daniel finkelstein supposed to be umbro's candidate for the messiah?
|
|
Roger Wilco
from Mo's Beans on 2024-03-17 22:32 [#02633592]
Points: 1998 Status: Lurker
|
|
Oh dear god, can you imagine?
|
|
mermaidman
on 2024-03-18 09:21 [#02633598]
Points: 8308 Status: Regular
|
|
this is norman finkelstein though, does he share messiah blood?
|
|
Tony Danza
from NAFO Suicide Hotline on 2024-03-18 12:15 [#02633599]
Points: 3647 Status: Regular
|
|
We have established that Norman Finkelstein is not the Messiah.
Finally, the XLT led peace process is making some headway.
|
|
RussellDust
on 2024-03-18 15:26 [#02633600]
Points: 16065 Status: Regular | Followup to Tony Danza: #02633599
|
|
He’s not the messiah, he’s a very naughty boy!
|
|
mermaidman
on 2024-03-18 15:28 [#02633602]
Points: 8308 Status: Regular | Followup to RussellDust: #02633600
|
|
who? daniel or norman?
|
|
dariusgriffin
from cool on 2024-03-18 15:44 [#02633603]
Points: 12410 Status: Regular
|
|
norman finkelstein is a piece of shit cosying up to holocaust deniers and isn't lex fridman some kind of elon musk stooge or something
why would you watch this
|
|
Tony Danza
from NAFO Suicide Hotline on 2024-03-18 23:50 [#02633627]
Points: 3647 Status: Regular
|
|
r/TrueOffMyChest/
|
|
RussellDust
on 2024-03-19 12:50 [#02633638]
Points: 16065 Status: Regular | Followup to mermaidman: #02633602
|
|
Brian. But yeah Umbro was talking about Daniel.
|
|
RussellDust
on 2024-03-19 12:50 [#02633639]
Points: 16065 Status: Regular | Followup to mermaidman: #02633602
|
|
Brian. But yeah Umbro was talking about Daniel.
|
|
RussellDust
on 2024-03-19 12:51 [#02633641]
Points: 16065 Status: Regular
|
|
Damn hospital wifi!
|
|
RussellDust
on 2024-03-19 12:51 [#02633642]
Points: 16065 Status: Regular
|
|
Damn hospital wifi!
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-19 12:56 [#02633643]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to dariusgriffin: #02633603 | Show recordbag
|
|
maybe for the other two guys, thought one is a zionist
i still haven't managed to watch
the finkelstein guy is controversial, don't know about these specific accusations
yeah, the host isn't great either
|
|
Tony Danza
from NAFO Suicide Hotline on 2024-03-19 13:37 [#02633648]
Points: 3647 Status: Regular
|
|
Best post in this thread wins a coupon for a free...
[squints at coupon] ...bacon pizza?!
|
|
Roger Wilco
from Mo's Beans on 2024-03-19 13:37 [#02633649]
Points: 1998 Status: Lurker
|
|
I love the whole "I hate the Jews and support thieir persecution but I'm not a Nazi" movement.
|
|
Tony Danza
from NAFO Suicide Hotline on 2024-03-19 13:39 [#02633650]
Points: 3647 Status: Regular
|
|
it is very simple
p.s. bacon pizza in the joke because it highlights Muslim-Jewish brotherhood in abstaining from the swine
|
|
Roger Wilco
from Mo's Beans on 2024-03-19 18:31 [#02633670]
Points: 1998 Status: Lurker | Followup to Tony Danza: #02633650
|
|
More bacon for me then. Though I did only recently find out you're not meant to eat blood. And I like Black Pudding.
|
|
Roger Wilco
from Mo's Beans on 2024-03-19 18:32 [#02633671]
Points: 1998 Status: Lurker | Followup to Tony Danza: #02633650
|
|
Many countries have gone to war for far fucking less than being existentially threatened. Anyone wetting themselves about that? No?
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-19 20:56 [#02633683]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Show recordbag
|
|
Finkelstein doesn't seem too bad to me. a bit odd, yes. it should be noted he's Jewish and his parents were the only holocaust survivors in their families
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_Finkelstein: On Holocaust denial In a July 2020 online discussion with British activists, Finkelstein called Holocaust denier David Irving "a very good historian". Finding insufficient the evidence of Richard J. Evans as the expert witness in Irving's unsuccessful libel action in 2000 against Deborah Lipstadt, who had labeled Irving a Holocaust denier, Finkelstein said Irving had "produced works that are substantive … If you don't like it, don't read it. In the case of Irving, he knew a thing or two—or three".[125]
In October 2020, Finkelstein published an extract from his forthcoming book, Cancel Culture, Academic Freedom and Me on his website following the banning of Holocaust denial from Facebook and Twitter. According to Finkelstein, "Holocaust denial should be taught in university and preferably by a Holocaust denier" as a means "to inoculate students" against it. He states: "If one is committed to the purity of truth, not just in its wholeness but also in its parts, then a Holocaust denier performs the useful function of ferreting out 'local' errors, precisely because he is a devil’s advocate—that is, fanatically committed to 'unmasking' the 'hoax of the 20th century.'"[126][127]
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-19 20:57 [#02633684]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to big: #02633683 | Show recordbag
|
|
should be noted because also i didn't know this about him
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-19 21:04 [#02633685]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to big: #02633684 | Show recordbag
|
|
well and it's not irrelevant
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-19 21:10 [#02633686]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Show recordbag
|
|
(also i have looked into this before, i'm pretty sure, because i'm following him on Twitter. probably because bad empanada has mentioned him)
|
|
Roger Wilco
from Mo's Beans on 2024-03-19 22:00 [#02633687]
Points: 1998 Status: Lurker
|
|
Big. Why do you hate Jews?
|
|
Tony Danza
from NAFO Suicide Hotline on 2024-03-19 23:20 [#02633697]
Points: 3647 Status: Regular
|
|
That's great Roger, I hope you're keeping track of these zingers in woke_destroyer.rtf
Use Comic Sans to be extra cheeky.
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-20 07:47 [#02633710]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to Roger Wilco: #02633687 | Show recordbag
|
|
why do you hate brown people?
(pretty genuine question: islamophobia intersects with that greatly.)
also what Fleet says, with 'it is very simple' (i'd include civilians with journalists and kids, though)
i started watching: it's very informative and it has some interesting dynamics (like: the zionist is also respected for his historic work, by the other side)
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-20 07:47 [#02633711]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to Tony Danza: #02633697 | Show recordbag
|
|
well said
|
|
dariusgriffin
from cool on 2024-03-20 13:36 [#02633719]
Points: 12410 Status: Regular
|
|
don't call people "zionists" as a pejorative unless you want to alienate jews (including leftist jews). if what you mean is "supporter of the far right israeli government and the massacre of palestinians", say it as such.
|
|
Roger Wilco
from Mo's Beans on 2024-03-20 13:59 [#02633720]
Points: 1998 Status: Lurker | Followup to big: #02633710
|
|
Fuck Islam, sure I'm Islamophobic. Who wouldn't be? It's a violent crock of shit. Prove to me it isn't. What do you know about Islam? Bearing in mind they won't let you into their mosque to casually browse their DVDs and browser history. What with you in your pink shorts.
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-20 14:07 [#02633721]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to dariusgriffin: #02633719 | Show recordbag
|
|
i mean it a 'zionist'. his wiki page says he calls himself that. would be odd if he wasn't. like: would be odd to be a scholar and in support of Israel's politics and not be a zionist
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-20 14:44 [#02633723]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to dariusgriffin: #02633719 | Show recordbag
|
|
why would it be that bad, though? i don't think zionism is good. and the far right israel government is rooted in it (as is the state Israel)
|
|
Roger Wilco
from Mo's Beans on 2024-03-20 15:00 [#02633724]
Points: 1998 Status: Lurker | Followup to big: #02633723
|
|
Most Jews are zionists, ie they believe Israel has a right exist as the home of the Jewish people. You're against that. You'd rather there was yet another failed Islamic state. Why? Because you're a poof.
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-20 15:03 [#02633727]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to Roger Wilco: #02633724 | Show recordbag
|
|
there's plenty of antizionist Jews
leave my threads alone, please, go yell in the street
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-20 15:06 [#02633728]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to big: #02633727 | Show recordbag
|
|
or that's what it looks like, now, yelling in the street. a forest would be more preferable, or take up kungfu
|
|
mermaidman
on 2024-03-20 15:45 [#02633729]
Points: 8308 Status: Regular | Followup to Roger Wilco: #02633720
|
|
then why is it a problem for you if someone hates jews? (not that anyone here hates jews)
|
|
mermaidman
on 2024-03-20 15:51 [#02633730]
Points: 8308 Status: Regular
|
|
big is responsible for these threads every time. i remember him saying he didn't like the discord because ppl talked politics there in the politics thread (don't remember what it was called) that is now closed and 90 percent of his threads are like this here
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-20 16:26 [#02633732]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to mermaidman: #02633730 | Show recordbag
|
|
it very little of my threads, but the threads get too much engagement
it's only two threads
also the intend of the two threads was benign
|
|
RussellDust
on 2024-03-20 21:12 [#02633745]
Points: 16065 Status: Regular | Followup to Roger Wilco: #02633720
|
|
Shame. You sound like my Dad, who’s a good man but becoming twisted with hatred.
Of course there’s good in Muslim faith and Muslim people.
What was Christianity up to when it was roughly the age Islam is now? ‘Member? In my worthless opinion it’s all down to interpretation and the fact some rather scary people decided stuff had to be rigorously taken word for word and no interpretation was allowed.
Funny how most Islamic terrorists (the ones who actually do the nasty work, not those who plan it) were known to play video games, smoke weed and drink beer.
Roger, no one in their right mind would accept terrorism as being the correct way. But I also think it’s extreme to put everyone in the same basket. In its youth Islam was the religion of science, art and poetry. Some people are cunts, that’s all. All over the place.
|
|
RussellDust
on 2024-03-20 21:14 [#02633746]
Points: 16065 Status: Regular
|
|
Also I have to agree with big, not all Jewish people believe in the state of Israel as a right.
What is it with generalising everything?
|
|
mermaidman
on 2024-03-20 21:33 [#02633747]
Points: 8308 Status: Regular | Followup to RussellDust: #02633746
|
|
now that he's a jew he can speak for all of the jews
|
|
dariusgriffin
from cool on 2024-03-21 03:59 [#02633750]
Points: 12410 Status: Regular | Followup to big: #02633723
|
|
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Types_of_Zionism
|
|
dariusgriffin
from cool on 2024-03-21 04:08 [#02633751]
Points: 12410 Status: Regular
|
|
and so, you know, i'm not a big fan of nations and borders and all, but goys singling out jews and disapproving of them for wanting a jewish state after a couple millennia of persecution is a bit inconsiderate at best
|
|
dariusgriffin
from cool on 2024-03-21 04:21 [#02633752]
Points: 12410 Status: Regular
|
|
but if you want a more practical answer: anyone who's just a tiny bit attuned to antisemitism encounters the word more often as a sort of euphemical slur than as a meaningful descriptor, and that is how it will come across
|
|
mermaidman
on 2024-03-21 08:46 [#02633753]
Points: 8308 Status: Regular
|
|
what about the new york tunnel jews? they didn't let them keep their tunnel either
|
|
big
from lsg on 2024-03-21 19:13 [#02633778]
Points: 23698 Status: Regular | Followup to dariusgriffin: #02633752 | Show recordbag
|
|
i'll try not using it as a slur
i guess i meant political zionist, here, specifically
|
|
Roger Wilco
from Mo's Beans on 2024-03-21 19:24 [#02633779]
Points: 1998 Status: Lurker
|
|
They won't thank me, but what Darius said.
|
|
dariusgriffin
from cool on 2024-03-22 01:23 [#02633800]
Points: 12410 Status: Regular | Followup to big: #02633778
|
|
honestly, bar some very specific expert contexts, at this point i just don't see how the word could be useful in political discourse, except for raging antisemites to maintain plausible deniability. it's not worth the confusion if you're truly only using it to mean "supporter of the current israeli government" (which is a very reductive usage of a concept that has a very long and very broad history).
dan i don't want to ruin our moment but if you can't manage a she i'd really rather be he'd than they'd lol.
|
|
Messageboard index
|