Music theory question | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
(nobody)
...and 328 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2613461
Today 4
Topics 127500
  
 
Messageboard index
Music theory question
 

offline Monoid from one source all things depend on 2010-08-24 04:06 [#02390434]
Points: 11005 Status: Regular



So, i have a problem. I have tons of half finished on my
computer. I always come to the point where i have a basic
melody, drum loop etc going, and than suddenly i have no
clue what to do next. If i add further elements the starts
to sound like shit.
Sometimes i think be able to play a real instrument would be
really benefitting my music...Anyway, how can i improve my
skills in this area?


 

offline Altron Browm to on 2010-08-24 04:41 [#02390435]
Points: 11 Status: Lurker



you need to work on your composition skills.


 

offline llc from United States on 2010-08-24 05:06 [#02390436]
Points: 250 Status: Regular



Learn to read music, it's ALWAYS a plus. I played clarinet
in band (from grade school - high school), so I had a leg up
when I started learning classical guitar. I would suggest
taking piano lessons from a reputable teacher (see if you
can't schedule lessons with a piano professor from a
university near you).

This will help you IMMENSELY in many things. You will be
able to play melodies faster and easier when writing, and if
you decide to learn some theory (which I definitely
recommend), it will be much, much easier.

One thing that I like to do when I'm stuck on a song is
change the time signature. It's nice, because it forces you
to think a little differently in order to find the right
melody and rhythm. There are also several techniques you can
find in some modern classical music that I find especially
helpful when trying to decide what to do (listen to a bunch
of Steve Reich and Philip Glass).

Good luck, and have fun. =|:{D


 

offline llc from United States on 2010-08-24 05:09 [#02390437]
Points: 250 Status: Regular



OOPS, I forgot.

When you have learned how to read & write music (should be
much easier after taking piano lessons for a while), you can
start taking composition lessons if you're still getting
stuck (again, preferably through a reputable university).

Alas, when all else fails, smoke some heat nugget.


 

offline JivverDicker from my house on 2010-08-24 05:17 [#02390438]
Points: 12102 Status: Regular | Followup to llc: #02390436



Post some of your music to illustrate your point.


 

offline wavephace from off the chain on 2010-08-24 05:28 [#02390439]
Points: 3098 Status: Lurker



sometimes as they say less is more monoid. its good to
understand the simple song structures like A-B-A-B-A then
make the more complex 1s. take for example some of the
gaysex twins songs like fartlord danglehough, dwopples theme
and hola mi brola (they can be listened on LAZY_TITLE).
all those 3 are just simple A-B-A-B-A songs sometimes with
more drums/basslines/etc added in the 2nd A or B. dwopples
theme is just very simple waltz song with only 2 parts (bass
and lead) & strictly follows A-B-A-B-A it is still a good
song. once u get that you can start with more complex
structure with C &, D sections etc. and thinks like drum
breaks/solos, instrument solos etc. example gaysex twin
songs with more advance structure are the sharked man & get
ur cool on (from the gaysex twin ep gaysex twin presents
music from the hit video game cool spot 2: make 7 up yours)
sometimes its good to decide the structure early in when
your making your song. for example now im working on a song
with roger dancemore called IN THE HOLO-BROTHEL for the
upcoming roger dancemore album titled ROGER DANCEMORE. the
song is not done yet but i already know which for it takes.

intro
verse 1
inst chorus
verse 2
synth solo
drum break
inst chorus
verse 1 repeated
inst chorus
fade out

i hope this tips can make you more productive monoid. but
sometimes you wanna make a different song, not with form
like that but different style, growing and/or shifting. its
popular with idm artists or minimal techon. i would not say
constantly grow only layers, but also shift/change, drop out
parts to keep on the interest.


 

offline AMPI MAX from United Kingdom on 2010-08-24 06:24 [#02390442]
Points: 10789 Status: Regular



wavetallica phude isn't wrong about the a b a b a thing.
when you make a song you shouldnt really build it by just
adding layers you should move into new sections. but there a
lot of songs that dont do that (like most the analords). its
hard to prescribe a general rule of approach as its usually
really specific to the kind of music you naturally make.
youll get into a groove if its something you really like
doing


 

offline mohamed from the turtle business on 2010-08-24 12:58 [#02390458]
Points: 31145 Status: Regular | Followup to AMPI MAX: #02390442 | Show recordbag



right

everytime theres a thread like this, and ppl start talking
music theory, the thread dies about music theory

learning to like the way you work first is the hardest task
of all

if you jump from 0 to theory, it can be heard


 

offline Indeksical from Phobiazero Damage Control (United Kingdom) on 2010-08-24 13:07 [#02390459]
Points: 10671 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



Unfortunately monoid I think you need at least a little
imagination and creativity.


 

offline Fah from Netherlands, The on 2010-08-24 13:43 [#02390463]
Points: 6428 Status: Regular | Followup to Indeksical: #02390459



what she said ^


 

offline Steinvordhosbn from London (United Kingdom) on 2010-08-24 13:59 [#02390465]
Points: 3185 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



Plus, you're a cunt.


 

offline ijonspeches from 109P/Swift-Tuttle on 2010-08-24 14:07 [#02390467]
Points: 7841 Status: Lurker | Show recordbag



maybe this could help:
if you have a nice meldoy going and dont find another one to
follow, you can try to spread it out a bit, by not playing
all notes immedeatly. divide the melody you have onto two or
more instruments that work together, this way it wont become
boring so fast. maybe splitting the whole thing up makes it
easier to jam along a new melody to parts of your original
aswell.

its really strange. when i started making music and
listening precisely how music works, i found out so many
things, most of the time while walking around with
headphones on.
yet, when i start a new song i cant remember a lot of that
and sometimes i think, if i would remember all that and
transpose it, id be a good musician by now...


 

offline mohamed from the turtle business on 2010-08-24 17:51 [#02390490]
Points: 31145 Status: Regular | Followup to ijonspeches: #02390467 | Show recordbag



when you start a new track you should remember all that by
doing.
the proof that you're doing something you did before is
hearing something you've heard before. and build upon it.
strong foundations,, that's the way it works. the rest is
bullshit


 

offline jnasato from 777gogogo (Japan) on 2010-08-25 18:49 [#02390586]
Points: 3393 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



What I "put next" in my tracks, is what I hear coming next.
Feel the flow, and then put down what you feel. Same for
lead melodies or other melodic, harmonizing parts-- I just
listen to where there is nothing, to hear what my head puts
there. And then I put it.

...like listening to a looping bassline-- eventually, yo'
miiind will put a melody there (or put whatever you're
wanting to put over the bassline).

Analogous to drawing: a circle on a page can be anything.
Looking at it, you can feel a smiley face, or an earth, or
an eyeball, or a skating rink from above, etc. etc. Just
feel, and then put what you feel.

If you can't feel your own music, that's a huge problem!
Get into it and be all like, "yeeeh, aaaaw, Yyheeaahah!!"
etc.


 

offline Monoid from one source all things depend on 2010-08-25 19:12 [#02390591]
Points: 11005 Status: Regular | Followup to Indeksical: #02390459



For electronic music? Lol, dude please, i think thats a
myth.


 

offline -crazone from smashing acid over and over on 2010-08-25 21:05 [#02390605]
Points: 11233 Status: Regular | Followup to Monoid: #02390591 | Show recordbag



also try wearing a pink tutu..


 

offline EVOL from a long time ago on 2010-08-27 04:29 [#02390737]
Points: 4921 Status: Lurker | Followup to wavephace: #02390439



you gotta make the music your bitch, be the alpha maker!


 

offline yann_g from now on 2010-08-29 21:53 [#02391004]
Points: 3772 Status: Lurker



whatever i do i keep improvising in my head on the last
thing i heard. if you do the same, just play your tune then
stop it and start washing your dishes, some progression will
pop out when you don't pay attention. time to stop washing
your dishes and get back to work!


 

offline j4ck from United Kingdom on 2010-08-29 22:05 [#02391006]
Points: 1102 Status: Regular



monoid, go to a club and see what the
d-d-d-d-d-jays do


 


Messageboard index