How many musicmakers have actual musical training? | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
Now online (1)
nanotech
...and 306 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2614367
Today 13
Topics 127560
  
 
Messageboard index
How many musicmakers have actual musical training?
 

offline Deathsmith from Brussels (Belgium) on 2002-05-22 17:43 [#00230101]
Points: 1027 Status: Regular



I use FruityLoops V.3.4, and I've been making music for
about a month now. Some of it really is incredible, and I
think it really helped that I have some musical knowledge,
so that I know about the different notes, chords, and other
such things. . . it also helps me get an ear for the music,
to know what clicks to a listener, know what sounds good.

Alot of you fellows make music, using various different
programs, but do any of you know shit about writing actual
music?


 

offline Sido Dyas from a computer on 2002-05-22 17:45 [#00230103]
Points: 8876 Status: Lurker



No , not at all.
I wish i did sometimes.....


 

offline Netlon Sentinel from eDe (Netherlands, The) on 2002-05-22 17:46 [#00230104]
Points: 4736 Status: Lurker



i've played guitar for a few years now without any training
whatsoever, and the only letdown is that i can't write down
the things i invent when i'm jamming. that's what i like
about fruity loops, you don't have to be able to read notes


 

offline Deathsmith from Brussels (Belgium) on 2002-05-22 17:47 [#00230105]
Points: 1027 Status: Regular



Hmmm, well look at Aphex Twin!!! He never really learned
piano or anything when he was young, he didn't take music
lessons!


 

offline Nexus 6 from Netherlands, The on 2002-05-22 17:48 [#00230106]
Points: 3221 Status: Lurker



I've playing guitar for about 9 years sice I was 6. I play
in 3 different bands. I've been singing for 5 years. I can
drum and play piano and bass of course.
And I also make electronic music.
Answer to your question:
YES I have musical knowledge, a lot of it actually


 

offline Netlon Sentinel from eDe (Netherlands, The) on 2002-05-22 17:48 [#00230107]
Points: 4736 Status: Lurker



neither did jimi hendrix, right?


 

offline Deathsmith from Brussels (Belgium) on 2002-05-22 17:48 [#00230108]
Points: 1027 Status: Regular



I guess. . .


 

offline hepburnenthorpe from sydney (Australia) on 2002-05-22 18:52 [#00230211]
Points: 1365 Status: Lurker



i have played guitar for the past 19 years, played and sang
in a band for the last eight of that, and just jammed heaps
before that.

over my lifetime i would have written 100's of songs. i have
no formal training, but a good ear.

for me, its all in the structure. i guess i have a good idea
of how to piece something together.

somehow now, i wish id'e stuck with piano as a kid, instead
of moving into guitar. i meen i loved playing in bands and
all, but i wish i could play piano better now that im making
electronic stuff.

thorpe


 

offline Thelonious Punk from *fap fap fap* on 2002-05-22 19:01 [#00230218]
Points: 581 Status: Lurker



what the hell? Everyone from the 60's and 70's was a self
taught guitarist.. If you wanted guitar lessons during that
time you had to scour as hard as possible and you'd end up
with a classical acoustic guitar teacher that would
criticize and ignore rock. So yeah, jimi was self taught, a
lot of guitarists were..

I didn't know however that richard never took an instrument
up..hmm..so he never even taught himself anything? Its all
just natural and from his head without any structural
learning or basis?! Wow, that's talent I must say.



 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-05-22 19:03 [#00230221]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Show recordbag



I was taught violin formally and I sang in a church choir.


 

offline Thelonious Punk from *fap fap fap* on 2002-05-22 19:04 [#00230222]
Points: 581 Status: Lurker



I'm *Still* self teaching myself.. I don't think you ever
really stop but yeah.. That richard thing seems a little odd
to me is all.

I need vocal lessons just because... I need them.



 

offline B3n from Manchester (United Kingdom) on 2002-05-22 19:06 [#00230225]
Points: 4700 Status: Lurker



I've got music theory and played a brass instrument for 8
years


 

offline smeagle from Portland (United States) on 2002-05-22 19:16 [#00230235]
Points: 88 Status: Lurker



I played trombone from age 12 ~ 17, had a band director in
High School who was a facist dictator....pissed me off, so I
quit.

Three years ago I bought a Roland XP-60, bought a book on
harmony, looked a a couple of theory sites, and have taught
myself a bit of piano, with enough theory to give a a
general direction....

Most of my friends a good musicians...yet I'm making the
most insane stuff musically out of all of them (not
neccessarily 'good' just 'insane'). I feel sometimes that
they're really imprisoned by the things they learned in
music school.....

I mean, I do chord progressions on a whim, cuz they sound
good to me, yet they were always told that those
progressions are 'wrong' or 'bad'......so I cherrish the
freedom....


 

offline marlowe from Antarctica on 2002-05-22 19:38 [#00230245]
Points: 24600 Status: Regular



i am a classically-trained pianist with compositional
training. i've written sonatas/waltzes/preludes &tc for solo
piano.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2002-05-22 20:29 [#00230286]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to marlowe: #00230245 | Show recordbag



And jolly good they are too :)


 

offline raimons from Stockholm (Sweden) on 2002-05-22 20:42 [#00230305]
Points: 4266 Status: Lurker



well... i took drum lessons for about 4 years when i was i
kid.
and i can play i little bit of piano and guitar. that about
it...


 

offline marlowe from Antarctica on 2002-05-22 20:46 [#00230307]
Points: 24600 Status: Regular | Followup to Ceri JC: #00230286



gosh, thanx ceri - i shall dedicate my next Opus to you :)


 

offline shibumi from United States on 2002-05-22 20:47 [#00230308]
Points: 359 Status: Lurker



I'm a master of the skin flute



 

offline jingle from London (United Kingdom) on 2002-05-22 20:55 [#00230319]
Points: 502 Status: Regular



i have actually found that the more i learn about music the
less intersting my tracks become: i have to spend a while
unlearning stuff or else it becomes a bit too rigid. i like
to play with my food before i eat it...


 

offline chapman from United Kingdom on 2002-05-22 20:58 [#00230325]
Points: 1134 Status: Moderator | Show recordbag



piano :)


 

offline REFLEX from Edmonton, Alberta (Canada) on 2002-05-22 21:01 [#00230332]
Points: 8864 Status: Regular



Yeah I can write actual music on the drums, bass and guitar.
I know a little piano, and can play those other three
alright, especially the bass guitar. I took lessons about 7
years ago for the bass, but I had been playing even before
that.


 


Messageboard index