automatic versus manual | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
Now online (2)
dariusgriffin
big
...and 409 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2614104
Today 1
Topics 127542
  
 
Messageboard index
automatic versus manual
 

offline Ezkerraldean from the lowest common denominator (United Kingdom) on 2006-10-19 05:12 [#01989202]
Points: 5733 Status: Addict



why do americans always have automatic cars? they suck! you
cant wheelspin with them!


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-19 05:17 [#01989205]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Show recordbag



The only automatic car I've ever enjoyed was a (new type)
Civic with Honda's sportshift system. Essentially you can
switch between fully auto and a setup that emulates a rally
car's clutchless sequential gearbox. Banging it up and down
the box with the accelerator pinned was great fun.

The reason Americans have automatics is that they have long
distances to travel and automatics are less tiring to drive.
Also, they tend to have huge engines by european standards
and large low revving "lazy" engines suit automatics well
(needs fewer gearchanges so smoother).

I agree that generally though, automatics are not very
engaging at all and I can't ever see myself buying one. The
depreciation on them is massive too (particularly on
anything remotely sporty) as most people feel the same way
about them.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-19 05:18 [#01989207]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to Ceri JC: #01989205 | Show recordbag



*I forgot to mention I managed to wheelspin the automatic
Civic. Done by banging down 2 gears in the wet while gassing
it.


 

offline Wolfslice from Bay Area, CA (United States) on 2006-10-19 05:19 [#01989208]
Points: 4910 Status: Lurker



I'm American, and I never learned to drive a manual. Now i'm
just too lazy to learn.

Plus I like keeping my left leg tucked comfortably under my
right leg.


 

offline mimi on 2006-10-19 12:12 [#01989450]
Points: 5721 Status: Regular



i like to drive my manual but an automatic isn't so bad, you
can talk on your cell phone, eat breakfast, put on mascara
and crash into the car in front of you all at once!


 

offline LuminousAphid from home (United States) on 2006-10-19 18:19 [#01989630]
Points: 540 Status: Lurker | Followup to Ezkerraldean: #01989202



i can wheelspin with mine. but i'm just that cool.
i know how to drive a manual but i'd rather have an
automatic hands-down. too much of a hassle to fiddle with
gears every time you come to a stop light, which there are
many around here.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-19 19:59 [#01989637]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to mimi: #01989450 | Show recordbag



I see school run mums managing all that in manual cars
almost daily.


 

offline bogala from NYC (United States) on 2006-10-19 20:09 [#01989638]
Points: 5125 Status: Regular



i learned how to drive on a manual. My grandparents who
taught me think automatic is lazy. It does demand more
attention.


 

offline bogala from NYC (United States) on 2006-10-19 20:09 [#01989639]
Points: 5125 Status: Regular



My grandparents are insane though


 

offline swift_jams from big sky on 2006-10-19 20:12 [#01989641]
Points: 7577 Status: Lurker | Followup to Ezkerraldean: #01989202



OHohohoh...YES YOU CAN! :D I found out the hard way! In the
rain too of all things. Hydroplaning is fucking awesome when
there are no other cars and you're going 75 on a 55 road. ;)


 

offline bogala from NYC (United States) on 2006-10-19 20:40 [#01989650]
Points: 5125 Status: Regular



Isn't there a new sport involving spinning out?


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-19 20:41 [#01989651]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to bogala: #01989650 | Show recordbag



Drift racing?


 

offline Anus_Presley on 2006-10-19 20:44 [#01989652]
Points: 23472 Status: Lurker



manuals might be harrderr to learrn, but they'rre not
harrderr to drrive and rreally... they don't take any morre
attention i wouldn't think. i've neverr drriven an
automatic, i wouldn't want to, it'd feel horrrrible.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-20 02:13 [#01989724]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to Anus_Presley: #01989652 | Show recordbag



IMO, manuals do take marginally more attention, but this is
offset by the fact you have more control over the car's
acceleration and deceleration. The only time I was glad to
be driving an automatic, rather than manual version of a
given car was when I was feeling very ill (some sort of
glandular infection) and was having to really concentrate
and still was only able to drive safely at about 5mph less
than the speed limit. It was nice to just have to think
about "stop and go, left and right" and I could see the
appeal for people who are poor drivers.


 

offline Taxidermist from Black Grass on 2006-10-20 06:08 [#01989777]
Points: 9958 Status: Lurker



Automatics have a better resale value than manuals. I tried
learning how to drive a manual and I nearly destroyed the
transmission.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-20 06:34 [#01989796]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to Taxidermist: #01989777 | Show recordbag



Not in the UK (and to a lesser extent, Europe in general).
We hate them.

I can understand why in America manuals would be harder to
resell.

Out of interest, roughly what proportion of people with
licences have manual licences in America?


 

offline Taxidermist from Black Grass on 2006-10-20 06:36 [#01989797]
Points: 9958 Status: Lurker | Followup to Ceri JC: #01989796



Do you need a separate licence to drive manual than
automatic in UK?


 

offline Taxidermist from Black Grass on 2006-10-20 06:39 [#01989799]
Points: 9958 Status: Lurker



If your talking about how many people own manual cars, I
would say out of the fifteen or so people I know that own
cars, only my sister has a manual. The number would be
different in rural areas (about half of canada's population
is rural) so perhaps 1 in 7, I would guess.


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-20 06:44 [#01989807]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to Taxidermist: #01989797 | Show recordbag



In the UK, if you pass your test in a manual, you can drive
either an automatic or a manual. If you learn in an
automatic, you need to redo your test in a manual in order
to be able to drive a manual. The only people who have
automatic licences tend to be the disabled, or women who
learn to drive later in life and can't really get the hang
of it.

I imagine in rural areas, more people learnt to drive on
tractors and hence already know how to use manuals?


 

offline Rostasky from United States on 2006-10-20 06:49 [#01989812]
Points: 1572 Status: Lurker | Followup to Ceri JC: #01989807



I live in a very rural area and learned on a (standard) work
truck. Most people where I live drive standards, but there
aren't that many people that live there.


 

offline Ezkerraldean from the lowest common denominator (United Kingdom) on 2006-10-20 06:52 [#01989820]
Points: 5733 Status: Addict | Followup to swift_jams: #01989641



but its not the same! with a manual you can wheelspin off at
every junction, in any weather! and redline with the clutch
down when you drive past someone you know, more polite than
beeping the horn ;)


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-20 07:07 [#01989839]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to Ezkerraldean: #01989820 | Show recordbag



I use the "dip the clutch and up the revs" trick to get
pedestrians (often drunks) to get out of the road. It
actually takes 2 seconds to visually gauge a car's speed
with any real sort of accuracy- most people, even if they
don't drive themselves, seem to base their initial view of a
car speeding up/slowing down on engine noise. In short, you
trick them into thinking you're speeding up, when actually
you're slowing slightly.


 

offline Ezkerraldean from the lowest common denominator (United Kingdom) on 2006-10-20 07:09 [#01989842]
Points: 5733 Status: Addict



i like your style. what do you drive Ceri me boy?


 

offline Ceri JC from Jefferson City (United States) on 2006-10-20 07:17 [#01989850]
Points: 23533 Status: Moderator | Followup to Ezkerraldean: #01989842 | Show recordbag



All sorts; I get a new hire car pretty much every week. I
mainly ride bikes and prefer them for getting from a to b in
a "sporty" manner, but cars are convenient for work
sometimes.

I've just handed back my favourite "big car" so far; a
petrol Vectra SRI with sat nav. It's the only car I've ever
unintentionally wheelspun due to power (as opposed to losing
grip when taking the piss cornering). Even in the dry,
without the touching the clutch, press the accelerator too
hard and it'll start wheelspinning. I've had it once before
a few months back. Last time I had it, I drifted it a
complete 360 round a mini roundabout.

They look nice too; if you put a matt black Irmscher grill
in it and debadged it, but kept the rest stock it'd look
superb.


 

offline redrum from the allman brothers band (Ireland) on 2006-10-20 08:14 [#01989867]
Points: 12878 Status: Addict



i hate automatics.

buy a manual, you have far more control over the movement
and behaviour of the car.

also, automatic gearboxes are notoriously unreliable.


 


Messageboard index