|
|
|
B3n
from Sheffield on 2001-11-11 20:11 [#00050626]
|
|
I was recommended to make a new post out of this, and I think I should since its quite interesting.
I'm doing some research into the whole 'braindance' thing and was wonderiing if you'd agree that its predominantly male dominated and if so, you think of any reasons why? I can't really tell since I've never been to live performances etc.
Cheers,
Ben
|
|
B3n
from Sheffield on 2001-11-11 20:12 [#00050627]
|
|
SpaZpheX from PAlAcIlsuRRounDSouND on 21:08 11/11/2001 Well, i reckon, and don't all jump down my throat on this- it's just my opinion, but the music is kind of cold and calculating, the way it's made is much like constructing a fantastic new building. The end result is beautiful but the thinking behind it is mathmatical and practical. Male thinking, not female. Can anyone think of some electronic music which has female character?
This is a very interesting question you have raised and i really think you should start a new thread on it if you want lots of people to reply to it!
|
|
will
from trinidad on 2001-11-11 20:32 [#00050641]
|
|
no offence guy,,,but i really dont think it should make any difference,,,i havent heard of any except one but i think shes more photekish,,i'm sure not what youre lookin for,, her name is luccia or something,,,,,i dont understand why people even comprehend the fact that something is male of female dominated.
what difference does it make,,,please explain.....
|
|
B3n
from Sheffield on 2001-11-11 20:37 [#00050645]
|
|
Eh? I don't think you understand, I'm looking to see if there are any differences, and if so why not if it *should*. And the rest of what you are saying, I don't have a clue...
|
|
will
from trinidad on 2001-11-11 20:51 [#00050658]
|
|
really guy,,whats the difference,,,,all that matters is the music.....
if a woman is making good music i'll listen,,,so whats the difference,,,unless u wanna look at someone pritty ,,and if so just look at mtv or something..
i'm just asking guy, why are you interested,,,it makes no sence to me ,so explain,,,,,,,,i'm not tring to pic a fight ,,i just see no difference and wanna know why someone would......
|
|
B3n
from Sheffield on 2001-11-11 20:54 [#00050659]
|
|
I don't care if its a guy, girl or transexual. I'm doing a sociology paper into it, thats why I need to know peoples opinions on it.
|
|
will
from trinidad on 2001-11-11 21:16 [#00050671]
|
|
oh a paper,,,,,uh well u gat my opinion,, it dosent make a difference and shouldnt
|
|
B3n
from Sheffield on 2001-11-12 16:14 [#00051039]
|
|
Ok then, if you think that, then where are all the females on this board? Are they hiding? And its not about what you think it should be like, its what it is like and why.
|
|
jand
from Essex,Uk on 2001-11-12 16:31 [#00051060]
|
|
It's an interesting question...I agree with you, IDM does seem to be predominately male orientated but I think the same is true for most of the dance music sub-genres...Theres no getting away from the fact that it's quite a "Technical" musical form and maybe it's that side of things that makes it appeal more to guys...
But it's tricky area and trying to decide whether it's nature or nuture behind this sort of bias is very difficult to work out...there are probably much wider cultural reasons for this imbalance that go far beyond the music itself...
Have you read "Speed Tribes"? Theres some great stuff in there about Otaku in Japan: obsessive fans (generally male)...pop to your local lib and see if you can pick up a copy, it might give you some ideas or potential directions to investigate further...
Let us know how you get on...
|
|
Dresen
from Winchester, England on 2001-11-12 17:18 [#00051091]
|
|
What jand said.
Also (And I think this point has been made before) girls are less inclined to use messageboards/the internet generally, hence fewer people of the female persuasion here.
Also, Will: Like it or not, it's a fact that girls and blokes are different, in terms of the mind - hence it's quite possible that this kind of music is less appealing to girls than to guys. I know that a higher percentage of the blokes I know (even IRL) like Aphex Twin than the girls.
Also, elipsis marks are made with full stops, not commas.
|
|
oysterclam
from the briny deep on 2001-11-12 18:37 [#00051106]
|
|
i know mad girls that are really into aphex, and two days ago while on the phone with my girlfriend, i heard go plastic in the background.
|
|
seanc@seanc.co.uk
from Lincolnshire on 2001-11-12 19:06 [#00051119]
|
|
girlies like to dance. boys like to 'nod' (or braindance)
its not very often you see a girl stood there 'nodding'.
|
|
Messageboard index
|
|
|
|