My review for Selected Ambient Works 2 | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
(nobody)
...and 195 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2613463
Today 1
Topics 127501
  
 
Messageboard index
My review for Selected Ambient Works 2
 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 03:01 [#02377540]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



To prepare for this review I listened to all 25 tracks of
SAW2 in one sitting. And what an amazing experience it was,
I was surprised at how much I enjoyed some tracks after not
hearing them properly for a while. I'd advise it to anyone,
give SAW2 your full, undivided attention.

This was my first album by Richard D. James. I wanted to buy
it after hearing some of the tracks on the comedy series
Jam, which uses a lot of good ambient music. This was in
2006, and that is how I was introduced to Aphex Twin, and
IDM music in general.

This is easily one of the most powerful albums I have ever
heard. It ranges vastly from peaceful, tranquilizing
lullabies to highly disturbing recordings from the depths of
hell. Here is my review of the 25 tracks, I'll be including
the colours I see since I, too, have synaesthesia.

[cliffs]
Mood: Peaceful, relaxing.
Colours: Pink/purple and brown, with black voices.
A wonderful opener to this vast album, we are treated to a
medley of strange, distorted voices. It's quite hard to
describe, since they sound very real yet very different from
ordinary speech. The track develops with sublime, oriental
melodies. The high point of the track is when it collapses
at 4:57, into a series of almost silent, perfectly tranquil
tunes.

[radiator]
Mood: Claustrophobic, unnerving.
Colours: Strong red, with black circles and white wisps.
We're moving into spooky territory now, with the continuous
plodding of an evil tune. You feel trapped. You become
connected to this strange place. Half way through,
everything becomes ominously still. You pause, anticipating
something very frightening. This is a wonderful, vivid
track.


 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 03:02 [#02377541]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



[rhubarb]
Mood: Very relaxing, a feeling of loss.
Colours: Green, green/yellow, with black undertones.
This is one of the most relaxing tracks I will ever hear. A
simply perfect sound is producing melodies that can send one
into sheer bliss. Later in the track, if you're still awake,
you hear the most beautiful harmony of two different new
melodies. I cannot describe just how insanely beautiful this
is. Aphex Twin is a genius.

[hankie]
Mood: Energetic, very scary.
Colours: Brown, white and black textures.
And now for something completely different. This is a major
shift from the previous track, replacing relaxing ambient
vibes with something out of a horror show. There are
undertones of madness and insanity amongst the terrifying,
Arabian strings. It has a very tense, overwhelming feel to
it.

[grass]
Mood: Calm, eerie, unsettling.
Colours: Black, purple and white.
This is a lot more calm and downtempo than the previous
track, like the eye in the middle of the storm. It's a
different flavour of scariness, with haunting undertones and
very eerie moans and cries. This is what you would hear in
your head while walking down a medieval prison, feeling the
sorrows and entrapment of all the prisoners as you walk by.

[mould]
Mood: Calm, humble.
Colours: Black smudges with a green/yellow background.
This is a very beautiful track made out of a simple melody
carried by a strange, wonderful sound. Not much happens in
terms of musical development, but it's very enjoyable
nonetheless.

[ropes]
Mood: Spooky.
Colours: Red and pink, with hints of black.
This is quite a strange track. It's very relaxing and
peaceful, yet it carries a sense of fear and discordance.
Those eight notes hypnotise you with their repetition. And
on top of that, the track is full of extra little melodies
to keep things interesting. Wonderful stuff.


 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 03:03 [#02377542]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



[blur]
Mood: Calm, ominous.
Colours: Light green/blue, with black beats.
I find this track to be very, very relaxing. It's not just
the catchy, yet relaxing beats, but the many different
things going on in the background. There are lots of subtle
little melodies going on amongst the rest of the noises,
it's like a recording from an alien landscape. With so much
to hear, you can never get bored.

[weathered stone]
Mood: Playful, laid back.
Colours: Blue and light blue, with some white noises.
This track is more percussion based than many of the other
tracks on SAW2. And oh, what a catchy track it is! It has a
real groove to it, with layers of beats and strange noises
set to a series of playful, if not slightly unnerving
melodies. It's as if there's a lot of mischief going on, it
has that kind of sense of humour that Richard brings to his
work.

[tree]
Mood: Dark.
Colours: Black with vague hints of white.
It was only recently when I realized how much I loved this
track. It manages to do two quite different things very
well: send you into a state of pure relaxation, and haunt
you with feelings of fear and anxiety. Not many musicians
can do this. As the track progresses, the feelings become
more and more deeply entwined with you, as noises from the
very depths of darkness engulf your soul. You feel childlike
fear as you have never known it before, while at the same
time feeling too relaxed to do anything about it. You can
only continue, and hope that the light will come soon.


 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 03:03 [#02377543]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



[domino]
Mood: Playful, lightly spooky.
Colours: Pink, red and white.
Throughout this track, a complex melody endlessly repeats
itself. It bounces up and down with a cheeky grin on its
face, taking you through a riveting journey that moves
through some strange places. It carries a hypnotic feeling
of mystery. I had an experience with this track when I left
my CD player on while I was asleep, and when this track came
on, I remember hearing it in my dream and thinking that it
was a very annoying melody, and I wanted it to end. Strange,
because I've never really thought this is real life.

[white blur 1]
Mood: Eerie.
Colours: Golden yellow twinkles.
This track sounds like it's taken right out of a lucid
dream. And the really spooky thing about it is that he seems
to have reproduced it perfectly in his studio, a testament
to the true talent of Richard D. James. It reminds me of the
moments in the restored version of the 1937 film Lost
Horizon where the footage couldn't be found and the visuals
are replaced with seemingly random images, giving a jarring,
unsettling effect.

Blue Calx
Mood: Tranquil.
Colours: Blue with white circles.
Ah, Blue Calx. Easily one of the most relaxing, most
beautiful tracks on the album. A simple rhythm is put in
place to help you keep track of the time. The most exquisite
noise you could imagine, like a light, watery explosion, is
repeated four times over and over. The second repetition is
accompanied by another, even more exquisite noise. And with
ambient vibes taking you to higher and higher places of
relaxation, it all adds up to one of Richard D. James'
greatest tracks.


 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 03:04 [#02377544]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



[parallel stripes]
Mood: Ecstacy.
Colours: Grainy, fuzzy pink and white.
Unlike [rhubarb], which seems to get all the love it
deserves, I find that this track is severely underrated.
It's definitely up there with [rhubarb], Blue Calx and
[stone in focus] as a champion of relaxing ambient music.
That gentle analogue hum is simply heavenly. All the way
through the track, I feel the essence of pure bliss as I
float through an alien landscape with a chorus of harmonic
singing.

[shiny metal rods]
Mood: Upbeat, energetic.
Colours: Orange and yellow shapes, like tangled wires and
bars.
One of the more upbeat tracks on SAW2, this track has some
real groove. There's electricity in the atmosphere here, it
has the power of a tropical rainstorm, and it combines it
with a mash of tingling, sparky beats. To be honest, I don't
listen to it very often, but when I rediscover it, I don't
regret it.

[grey stripe]
Mood: Eerie, desolate.
Colours: Grey background, white shapes ranging from rough to
smooth.
Wow. Either this is a direct live recording of an alien
planet, or it's a perfect recreation of the noises in one of
Richard's lucid dreams. This is a really great exhibition of
surreal noises, from eerie breezes, to marine life wailing,
to the violent hisses of one of nature's mistakes. The
ending is amazing, displaying an analogue synth strobing and
detuning into hell.

[z twig]
Mood: Happy, mellow.
Colours: Smooth golden yellow circles.
Who could possibly say anything bad about this track?
Absolute perfection. This really shows Richard's talent for
crafting the happiest, most wonderful melodies known to man.
Every little note is simply beautiful, and the fact that,
somehow, they are building up into this amazing work of art
just blows me away every time.


 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 03:05 [#02377545]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



[windowsill]
Mood: Tribal, menacing.
Colours: Dark red with black undertones.
When I first got this album, this track was an early
favourite. I don't know, I guess I just loved the tribal
atmosphere it gives off, the main melody proves to be very
effective for something so simple. From the very beginning,
a sense of panic and anxiety touch your soul. You are
dragged into a world of danger as all the drums of the
jungle dance around you. There are some really catchy beats
in there, and it all adds up to a great track, even if it
isn't strictly ambient.

[stone in focus]
Mood: Dark, tranquil.
Colours: Grainy black.
And now for one of the most beautiful, relaxing and simple
tracks ever created. This track is built almost entirely on
three notes (High C, #C, #A) repeating over and over, with
some gentle tapping in the far background. Somehow, the
result of this track is vastly greater than the sum of its
minimalist parts. Every note takes my breath away. It's
hypnotic. It's relaxing. It's disturbing. It's beautiful.
It's the perfect track to play on a loop and fall asleep to.
This track is the king of ambience.

[hexagon]
Mood: Everything is OK.
Colours: An orange background with golden shines here and
there.
I adore this track. It's like lying down at a beach,
watching vibrant, alien skies and getting warmed up by a
burning, alien sun. It's full of exquisite melodies, and
each one is an important part of this masterpiece of
relaxation. Every second fills me with content, and as I
listen to this for six minutes, all my troubles seem to
disappear. Simply wonderful.


 

offline recycle from Where is Phobiazero (Lincoln) (United States) on 2010-04-24 03:05 [#02377546]
Points: 39976 Status: Regular



thanks and welcome to the board and 1994


 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 03:05 [#02377547]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



[lichen]
Mood: Deeply sad.
Colours: White balms.
Originally, I didn't like this track very much. Not that I
ever considered it to be poorly made, or ineffective. It
does its job very well, but that's precisely it. I've always
found [lichen] to feel incredibly sad, to the point where it
just feels like too much. I remember back in 2006 when I had
depression, and I found that listening to tracks like
[cliffs] and [rhubarb] helped a little. So, one day, I
listened to [lichen]. Big mistake. The sheer melancholy of
this track amplified my sadness, and I broke down in tears.
It's one of the very few tracks that has ever managed to
make me cry. But this is exactly what makes this track truly
great. Music is supposed to make you feel, not just feel
good, and this track certainly makes me feel.

[spots]
Mood: Eerie, claustrophobic.
Colours: Black smoke.
I consider this to be one of the lesser tracks on SAW2. But
that's not to say it's not a great track. It feels very
atmospheric, as if there are a lot of gases and substances
in the air. You can just make out creepy voices edging their
way into the track from each direction. It all adds up to a
well-produced feeling of claustrophobia. But still, it can
feel slightly dry at times, and there aren't many changes
overall. Perhaps the album would improve if this track was
replaced with the compilation track "Analogue Bubblebath 3",
which basically achieves the same effect but in a better
way.

[tassels]
Mood: A panic attack.
Colours: Clouds of circles in different shades of yellow.
This track is simply marvelous. A very effective feeling of
claustrophobia is produced by the squashy, distorted
dissolving of a delicious analogue synth. The sound is
haunting, even disturbing, but at the same time it manages
to relax you, and hypnotise you in typical SAW2 fashion.
There are moments when another synth appears on top, and it
feels like the track is literally scorching, getting really
hot. Basically, the atmosphere is amazing.


 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 03:06 [#02377548]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



[white blur 2]
Mood: Drowsy, spaced out.
Colours: Black background with smooth, orange and yellow
shapes.
You know, I think this track is very underrated. It's a
challenging track, with its sheer length and repetition, but
it can be very rewarding once you get into it. This track
strongly feels like sleep deprivation. Like if you stay
awake for a long amount of time, you feel all woozy and
drowsy. Your perception of reality begins to change shape.
This is the perfect track to accompany this state of mind,
and I've used it to great effect.

[matchsticks]
Mood: Grand, expansive.
Colours: A blur of light blue and white.
As the album draws to a close, we are left with an epic
finale. It starts off simple enough, with ominous taps and
strings to set the mood. Over time, these strings build a
tense atmosphere, revealing a new, secret alien world. You
see hot, sandy deserts, skies of strange colours, and great,
expansive monuments. The track has an eastern feel to it. It
climbs higher and higher, with a feeling of importance, of
grandeur. The track, and the album, ends rather suddenly,
with the remains of the ambient vibe quietly fading out.

So ends one of the greatest, strangest, most moving journeys
one could possibly undertake in the field of music. I hope
you have enjoyed reading my review. Now all that's left is
the rather challenging task of rating the 25 tracks in
order, from best to worst:

[rhubarb]
Blue Calx
[parallel stripes]
[lichen]
[hexagon]
[cliffs]
[stone in focus]
[z twig]
[grass]
[white blur 2]
[tree]
[hankie]
[ropes]
[blur]
[windowsill]
[radiator]
[matchsticks]
[tassels]
[weathered stone]
[domino]
[grey stripe]
[mould]
[shiny metal rods]
[white blur 1]
[spots]


 

offline Magi from TLN (Togo) on 2010-04-24 13:16 [#02377564]
Points: 88 Status: Lurker



and who will ever read all that?)
i think it is that kind of music...you know, personal? where
everyone sees his own stuff


 

offline recycle from Where is Phobiazero (Lincoln) (United States) on 2010-04-24 13:41 [#02377570]
Points: 39976 Status: Regular



I read bits and pieces Madonna, not the whole thing
yes its a superb album
just listened to CD02 about a month ago-ish.


 

offline ijonspeches from 109P/Swift-Tuttle on 2010-04-24 15:58 [#02377576]
Points: 7841 Status: Lurker | Show recordbag



i still listen to selections of these when going to sleep
has been a while since i had it all in one seating though


 

offline ijonspeches from 109P/Swift-Tuttle on 2010-04-24 16:00 [#02377577]
Points: 7841 Status: Lurker | Followup to ijonspeches: #02377576 | Show recordbag



its really music that enhances synesthesia.



 

offline doctordmx from Boogers & Boners on 2010-04-24 16:16 [#02377578]
Points: 199 Status: Lurker



cancer


 

offline Brisk from selling smack at the orphanage on 2010-04-24 17:30 [#02377581]
Points: 4667 Status: Lurker



sounds like a good album. i'll have to check it out


 

offline dave_g from United Kingdom on 2010-04-24 17:59 [#02377591]
Points: 3372 Status: Lurker



When is it released and who's it by?


 

offline Rhombix from THE ISLAND (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-24 19:03 [#02377593]
Points: 13 Status: Addict



It was released in 1994 by Aphex Twin, aka Richard D. James.
It's a bloody good album, but prepare to be surprised.


 

offline dave_g from United Kingdom on 2010-04-24 20:33 [#02377599]
Points: 3372 Status: Lurker | Followup to Rhombix: #02377593



Cool, never heard of it. Thanks.
I notice this is number 2. Does that mean there is a number
1?



 

offline recycle from Where is Phobiazero (Lincoln) (United States) on 2010-04-24 23:21 [#02377606]
Points: 39976 Status: Regular | Followup to dave_g: #02377599



lol, yeah yeah yeah get off his nuts
you know there is a #1 and a #3 wont happen
any time soon :(


 

offline yoyoyoyo from Sweden on 2010-04-25 01:30 [#02377622]
Points: 3200 Status: Regular | Followup to recycle: #02377606



do you mean v3?


 

offline rad smiles on 2010-04-25 02:23 [#02377626]
Points: 5608 Status: Lurker



best aphex video from saw 2. did he make this or is it fan made?


 

offline PS on 2010-04-25 05:30 [#02377638]
Points: 1876 Status: Lurker



Ever since I was a young boy, I've enjoyed watching people
dance. He knows this all too well..


 

offline jnasato from 777gogogo (Japan) on 2010-04-25 12:29 [#02377651]
Points: 3393 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



Unfortunately for you all, the review was actually voodoo.
By scrolling down, the magic switch was activated, and by
skimming- as stated in the actual review- you all agreed to
the curse.

Nice job, budz and budzettez--- you'ze all cursed! YOU ALL
NOW HAVE APHEX FACES!!! FEEL YOUR SMILE!!!!!
FuuUUUUuUUuUUuUuuUu


 

offline recycle from Where is Phobiazero (Lincoln) (United States) on 2010-04-25 13:34 [#02377660]
Points: 39976 Status: Regular



Voodoo+


 

offline AphexAcid from Sweden on 2010-04-25 15:42 [#02377677]
Points: 2568 Status: Lurker | Followup to rad smiles: #02377626



awesome video


 

offline pantalaimon from Winterfell (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-25 22:14 [#02377715]
Points: 7090 Status: Lurker | Followup to dave_g: #02377599 | Show recordbag



this is sarcasm right?


 

offline recycle from Where is Phobiazero (Lincoln) (United States) on 2010-04-25 22:25 [#02377716]
Points: 39976 Status: Regular | Followup to pantalaimon: #02377715



read the post right below his
post [#02377606]

dave's been here almost as long as we have
i think he has a clue


 

offline Steinvordhosbn from London (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-25 22:39 [#02377719]
Points: 3185 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



You fools, there's about 100 Selected Ambient Works, my
favourite ones are 85 to 92.


 

offline jnasato from 777gogogo (Japan) on 2010-04-25 23:06 [#02377720]
Points: 3393 Status: Regular | Followup to Steinvordhosbn: #02377719 | Show recordbag



AHAHAHA


 

offline dave_g from United Kingdom on 2010-04-26 19:47 [#02377809]
Points: 3372 Status: Lurker | Followup to Steinvordhosbn: #02377719



I was going to make that joke and now I'm not happy you've
beaten me.
Great minds think alike eh? hmmm



 

offline Steinvordhosbn from London (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-26 19:59 [#02377812]
Points: 3185 Status: Regular | Followup to dave_g: #02377809 | Show recordbag



Sorry, that was in response to your "I notice this is number
2. Does that mean there is a number 1?"... I guess we're
riffing off of each other with IDM-themed bon mots.


 

offline Terence Hill from Germany on 2010-04-26 20:05 [#02377813]
Points: 2070 Status: Lurker | Followup to Steinvordhosbn: #02377812



this new fangled sarcasm thingie you guys seem to be
making use of is a bit hard to follow though, be careful,


 

offline Steinvordhosbn from London (United Kingdom) on 2010-04-26 20:10 [#02377816]
Points: 3185 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



Type it up in beautiful code


 

offline Terence Hill from Germany on 2010-04-26 20:21 [#02377817]
Points: 2070 Status: Lurker



B===D ~~~


 

offline mohamed from the turtle business on 2010-04-26 23:49 [#02377838]
Points: 31145 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



today's special: rhubarb and thunderstorms


 

offline mohamed from the turtle business on 2010-04-27 00:05 [#02377844]
Points: 31145 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



grass + huge thunder


 

offline mohamed from the turtle business on 2010-04-27 00:26 [#02377847]
Points: 31145 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



there's no worst or best track imo, today i hate a track
that once made my day.. that's not the point



 

offline mohamed from the turtle business on 2010-04-27 00:34 [#02377849]
Points: 31145 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



i skipped weathered stone for instance


 

offline Magi from TLN (Togo) on 2010-04-27 18:13 [#02377969]
Points: 88 Status: Lurker



ambient sucks...


 

offline b77w4r from Gent (Belgium) on 2010-04-28 01:12 [#02378038]
Points: 32 Status: Lurker



saw II is the only album i have played + 1000 times. Words
would spoil it.


 

offline recycle from Where is Phobiazero (Lincoln) (United States) on 2010-04-28 01:29 [#02378046]
Points: 39976 Status: Regular | Followup to b77w4r: #02378038



play both brown records backwards together
and you get some great lyrics


 


Messageboard index