i'm begining to think IDM sucks... | xltronic messageboard
 
You are not logged in!

F.A.Q
Log in

Register
  
 
  
 
Now online (2)
dariusgriffin
belb
...and 550 guests

Last 5 registered
Oplandisks
nothingstar
N_loop
yipe
foxtrotromeo

Browse members...
  
 
Members 8025
Messages 2614087
Today 0
Topics 127542
  
 
Messageboard index
i'm begining to think IDM sucks...
 

offline larn from PLANET E (United Kingdom) on 2009-05-21 00:58 [#02292479]
Points: 5473 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



I have always liked 'sound design' 'sound sculpture' 'sound
architecture' more than actual music, notational
compositions etc

I used to listen to radio static when i was a young boy


 

offline cx from Norway on 2009-05-21 01:35 [#02292482]
Points: 4537 Status: Regular



I think that no artist really fits the perfect description
of "idm."
The term cannot save the music being played, much like the
music cannot save the term.
idm to me is one of the few genres which isnt actually a
genre, it's just a way to describe early warp records and
some other known labels in the 90's and early 00's.. no
matter how different those warp artists were, they all
became IDM.

nowadays i just associate idm with glitch, specifically
glitch effects and technical tricks in music, but then again
glitch is an own genre also.
but yeah idm = funny weird glitch noises. (to me)

part of the demise of this idm might also be that some
people started to become disappointed with the main warp
artists from early 00's - 06

even so you see on waffles and other sites many people still
follow all the idm artists, and new artists in the idm
category are downloaded a bunch too.. its like an open
secret where everyone says its dead but everyone also
downloads the new releases



 

offline cwnt on 2009-05-21 04:49 [#02292494]
Points: 951 Status: Regular



aphex twin, squarepusher etc will always be popular but
they are not idm artists thats why

idm the name and philosophy died because it is the american
interpretation of aphex twin's career but it is just a lie
spread by christpuncher (flashbulb) and other american kids
on joyrex.com 10 years ago. idm never existed, it's a
lie/misunderstanding spread on messageboards.


 

offline stoz on 2009-05-21 05:17 [#02292495]
Points: 168 Status: Lurker



the term idm was a big pile of shit i never bought into -
are the artists more intelligent than other producers? does
it make us more intelligent for listening to it? are we more
intelligent than other fans of electronic music?

music wise i cant speak for what's happening in idm at the
moment (if the movement even exists) but in other eletronic
genres i think its a very interesting time for electro house
/ dubstep / drum n bass and everything in between. zero chin
stroke factor, very good to dance to.


 

offline cx from Norway on 2009-05-21 07:21 [#02292520]
Points: 4537 Status: Regular | Followup to stoz: #02292495



i never liked the chin stroke factor in terms of music.
music is all about emotion.
people say autechre is so mathematical and algorithmipoo,
but in the end its not about that and those people are
clueless.

all music that appears to be that way must have some primal
emotional content or else it fails, for me at least.
emotions = associations doesnt necessarily mean dancable, it
can also mean brain dance ::


 

offline 2501 from United Kingdom on 2009-05-21 07:49 [#02292522]
Points: 22 Status: Regular



My problem here is with genres. I hate genres, they do
nothing for music except help people find things they like.
I remember reading an interview with Richard D James about
IDM, and he said something about how it made other peoples
music sound stupid. Tru dat.
Music is just vibrations in the air that does stuff to your
brain. Depending on how you view life, music will mean
different things, especially abstract music, which many a
time does not have a meaning. I suppose I'm stating the
obvious.
I'll end here by saying wether it is mind blowing or not is
completely up to what goes on in the listeners mind, and for
me, its all gud bruv. I'll keep the beats rolling till I
change!


 

offline stoz on 2009-05-21 07:54 [#02292523]
Points: 168 Status: Lurker



dont get me wrong i do like what a lot of people call 'idm'.
i can see why people might describe it as being
mathematical, however if i had to think about its
mathematical properties, at a conscious level, that would
detract from my enjoyment of the music (plus i know next to
nothing about maths). it affects me emotionally, and any
sort of mathematical association must be a purely
sub-conscious process.

take house music - it can be so structurally rigid - 16 bar
intro, 16 bar build up, break down after 32 / 64 bars, every
section neatly divided into segments of 8 bars. when you
hear this system being subverted its quite thrilling, in a
rather technical way. when i was at uni in my house the
maths / chemistry / physics heads liked aphex, the less
technically minded did not. huge generalisation, i know, but
i do think in some ways 'idm' makes perfect sense to some,
and yet is completely baffling to others.


 

offline mohamed from the turtle business on 2009-05-21 08:26 [#02292525]
Points: 31229 Status: Regular | Followup to 2501: #02292522 | Show recordbag



plain and simple

it's absolutely a subjective matter, one could be completely
deprived of the technical views on music and still pick
something and viceversa, for me its about who you are, what
you learnt from life, its about using a completely different
set of judgements cos you're not me. another funny thing is
that if you happen to do music, your output can gather an
amount of significance compared to the one that pushed you
to do that, or lose all of it. and everything cos decades
ago you heard that put-a-donk-on-it track at xltronic.


 

offline AMPI MAX from United Kingdom on 2009-05-21 08:39 [#02292529]
Points: 10789 Status: Regular



wait. it is more intelligent than basshunter. so its not
dance music....its more intelligent. also this whole turning
on idm as a genre is the next fashionable thing, like saying
'im agnostic' cos too many folks are atheists.


 

offline AMPI MAX from United Kingdom on 2009-05-21 08:40 [#02292530]
Points: 10789 Status: Regular



'fuck idm' is the new idm. just listen and shoosh


 

offline mohamed from the turtle business on 2009-05-21 08:57 [#02292535]
Points: 31229 Status: Regular | Followup to mohamed: #02292525 | Show recordbag



*unlearnt from life, that is


 

offline stoz on 2009-05-21 09:39 [#02292549]
Points: 168 Status: Lurker



bollocks. i first came across the term idm about 7/8 years
ago and though it was nonsense. im certainly not jumping on
the bandwagon before it disappears over the horizon. besides
peeps use it all the time here.


 

offline glasse from Harrisburg (United States) on 2009-05-21 11:08 [#02292568]
Points: 4211 Status: Regular | Followup to cwnt: #02292494 | Show recordbag



i don't think americans in the early 90s had the same
appreciation of techno as many europeans. most americans
who got into aphex twin and autechre early on did so through
crossover interests, (industrial, post-punk, no-wave). If
america were europe, everyone would have been into electro
and detroit and when aphex twin comes along it is just the
next step. except it really wasn't like that. i'd say more
american's that listened to ae and afx at this time were
more likely to also have ministry & big black in their
collection than phuture. rave culture was looked down on a
lot, and most techno was considered trite, so intelligent
dance music was coined and these artists were considered
acceptable to american beard strokers, while being too
into techno
remained something for "candy ravers and
transvestites."

of course in europe the term is rejected because of a richer
heritage in regards to electronic music. for many, aphex
twin and autechre are the natural progression of what they
already know. so the idea that this form of dance music is
intelligent while others are not is offensive, as it would
also be offensive to an american who was into detroit 1st
and then got into aphex twin.



 

offline Steinvordhosbn from London (United Kingdom) on 2009-05-21 11:13 [#02292569]
Points: 3185 Status: Regular | Show recordbag



i'd say more american's that listened to ae and afx at
this time were more likely to also have ministry & big black
in their
collection than phuture.


That was sort of me, but I was on the wrong side of the
Atlantic. I often think I should have been American, I just
do't have the right teeth I suppose.


 

offline cwnt on 2009-05-21 11:48 [#02292573]
Points: 951 Status: Regular



well said glasse you just wrote the truth


 


Messageboard index